RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/television • … • u/TheSecondEikonOfFire

Mr and Mrs Smith is one of the oddest shows I've ever seen with some frustrating logic choices *spoilers*

I'm a bit behind the curve here, but I just finished Mr. and Mrs. Smith and I'm not quite sure how I feel about it. I felt like I was constantly shifting back and forth between "okay I love this" and "what the hell is happening/why the hell did they do that".

If you don't want to read the whole post, my TL;DR is: it has great leads, excellent acting, and some great emotional development. But it has some weird tonal shifts with humor and the characters often behave in a way that makes no sense at all for alleged 'secret agents' to behave.

For the good stuff, I really liked the two leads. I thought Donald Glover was good, but I thought Maya Erskine was terrific. Especially in the last few episodes, she gets some terrific scenes to really showcase her acting chops. Visually, I thought the show looked great. Overall it was shot and edited well.

I love the idea of the core of the show focusing on this relationship between two people, and seeing their relationship at various stages of their careers as 'spies' or whatever they're technically considered. I loved seeing them develop more issues as a married couple, and trying to work out those issues while also killing people.

It also had some good humor. I really loved the episode with the therapist played by Sarah Paulson, especially because it adds the dynamic of them pretending to be software engineers, which I found very funny. As someone who is a software engineer, I thought they did a great job at having people who have no idea what software development entails trying to pretend that that's what they do. That's on top of them also having to make metaphors for what they were actually doing (carrying out a hit), and I thought that was hilarious.

But the humor was also one of the show's major pitfalls for me, because overall it felt very tonally confused. I love the Brad and Angelina movie, and that movie is just a silly over-the-top action flick. This show is clearly trying to do something different, and focus more on the actual relationship dynamic of two fundamentally flawed people, which is fine in theory. But there were instances throughout the show where they injected this really absurd comedy that just felt weirdly out of place - like in the episode with John Turturro, where he makes them get down and act like dogs? What was that about?

By far the most irritating aspect of the show though has to be the logic choices. We're not given much info about "the company", but I think it would be safe to assume that they monitor their agents very closely. Yet somehow they allow John to stay in contact with his mother _and_ move her out to NYC?

She knows about Jane, but doesn't call him 'John' when she talks with Jane in the finale, which implies that she doesn't know he's a spy. But he gives her a key to their house. So what exactly is his plan here? Not only is he now compromised because his mom lives nearby and he's out with her constantly (putting a target on her back), but how is he planning on keeping his identity hidden? He'd either have to never have his mom meet Jane (which is not only super unrealistic, but he gave his mom a damn key to their house), or somehow hope that his mom never mentions his real name when they're all together. So what happens if Jane refers to him as John? How is he going to explain that to his mom?

Another logical complaint I had was the episode where they go to Italy and kidnap Ron Perlman. They're supposed to be these super secret agents, they're wearing masks when they kidnap him and put a bag on his head. But then in the car they decide to just... let him take his hood off and still have their faces exposed? And then they take him to the house that John secretly bought, where he proudly states that it's a place that he bought for them to run away to and that no one else would know where it was. Except you just brought one of your targets there?? Not to mention that does he really think that their company wouldn't be aware of him buying property? I find that hard to believe.

I could keep going but I've already written a ridiculous amount of text for a Reddit post. Salute to anyone that actually read this far. Overall I think I did enjoy the show, but it was just such an odd show that felt like it didn't really know what it was trying to be. Or maybe it tried to be too much and wasn't able to pull it off.

— 0