RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/television • … • u/KBO_Winston

Sherlock Homes & Daughter - Review (tl;dr it's like the tv equivalent of graham crackers)

FYI: There's a tl,dr at the bottom, if my rant goes on too long. Also, I've only watched the first three eps (though the below applies to all of them) and I'm wicked progesterone drunk right now (iykyk), so... Bonus?

Also, despite being a Sherlock Holmes buff (not going into it but suffice to say my papers are in order), I just discovered this tonight. It's leaving Max soon, so if you want a light weekend binge, you're on the clock.

The Review: ....Have you ever had graham crackers? But nice ones - the kind dusted with cinnamon sugar ? That's Sherlock Holmes & Daughter. It's bland but also also consistent and honestly the extensive set decorating and costumes make it a treat. No one had a Merchant and Ivory boner working on this, it's the same mis-mash of patterns on patterns that real Victorian messiness did well - especially for the residence of someone who acts like interior decor ranks even lower than basic astronomy on the 'Skills I need to fit in my brain-attic' list. So there's actual fun involved in the design (that's the cinnamon sugar on the bland crackers).

(When I say well-appointed, I don't mean the budget seems high. In fact, props to the, well, props team for making a hundred candles and some gels go 100% on mood lighting. Seriously, doing a lot with a little and not relying every two seconds on CGI is a lost art. Nicely done!)

The downside is... Look, I don't think it was written with AI but it's certainly a triumph of human mediocrity. David Thewlis is so far from playing Sherlock Holmes he's basically playing Grumpy David Thewlis. But this actually... works in the the show's favor? There's no uncanny valley here - that's just straight up Not-Holmes.

The upside of this is instead of saying 'that's not Sherlock Holmes' at most scenes you're free to think "Oh, it's a well-designed Victorian mystery about Some Guy. I like Victorian mysteries. I can be cool with Some Guy. Player, play on!"

The absolute allergy to characterization doesn't stop with Holmes (although, side-note, phoning in a paper thin version of a character who's been done so well so many times he actually has held the record for most versions on screen is an absolute flex of 'you can't make **me** write characters!' It's almost backwards-impressive.)

The other characters start out thin and mainline Ozempic. Characters are SEXIST! And CLASSIST! At times, this is the extent of their character. It's often the extent of the "conflict." No one told the writers that effective conflict involves two POVs and, done well, the audience feels at least a small pull toward both sides when uncomfortably good points are made all around (or at least 'good considering where this person's coming from').

If I cold make aspiring writers do a Bart Simpson at the chalkboard job, it'd be to repeatedly write "Because you can't engage with their side bullies and bigots aren't effective conflicts. They're just bad weather." This series is like exhibit ALL OF THEM for this point.

Finally, the show almost nopes out of doing actual observations so fast, it's blink and you miss it. So instead, you get chyrons telling the audience not what Sherlock is seeing but what instruction he just CLEARLY and VERBALLY announced to his apprentice, like a computer game listing your quest goals. Actual Holmesian traits are so far from this series you're more likely to see Conan Doyle's fairies spring to life and offer to make you a flat white than to find Sherlock making observations here. But while this is so lazy I think even AI would balk at it, it actually does another good job of bolstering the Thewlis effect: This is so not-Holmes any comparison to Holmes feels beside the point.

The real lead character does a commendable job trying to elevate the material to something worthy of the name. Honestly, she and the design team did so much to drag these scripts from the brink of embarrassment through sheer force of talent and locking the fark in. I tip my deerstalker to them (a hat not \*really\* in the original stories but what are you gonna do? Icons gonna icon).

The pacing is also worth a shout-out. The narrative's generic and bland but moves so fast the eps fly by like... like realizing you just ate half a sleeve of graham crackers.

**tl and progesterone drunk to read**: It's terrible Sherlock rep, it's proof even with over a century of good examples to follow, humans can make slop all on their own, and I still had a good time. Get buzzed, make popcorn, yell at the screen when answers are obvious, enjoy the balls-to-the-wall commitment to make the low budget drip Victorian aura, and have a surprisingly good time!

Just view it more like a Sherlock adventure ride at Universal than an actual Sherlock series and you'll probably be fine.

ETA: I've now finished the season and can say they're far better with the plot than the characters. And as the final eps are far more plot-heavy, they work really well compared to the eps they started with. If someone's read this long and is wondering if it's worth it, try skipping the first 2 or 3 eps and you'll probably have a fun ride.

— 0