RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/television • … • u/Prestigious_Load1699

East of Eden - I have issues with the "beans" scene.

Adam erupts at Cal for so-called profiting off of the war.

Two problems with this:

The first is that when the bean futures were purchased, America *wasn't in the war yet*, and they were purchased *above market price*.

In other words, no one was ripped off, and no soldiers died for those beans. Caleb took a calculated (but very real) risk and it paid off. As a businessman, Adam should have respected the foresight and not allowed his qualms with war cloud the assessment of his son's achievement.

The second problem is arguably worse. Adam gambled his entire family's future on shipping hundreds of thousands of pounds of lettuce cross country. He took a similar gamble with a food item and failed miserably.

Bottom line is this - those beans fed soldiers, and Adam's lettuce rotted. He's a giant hypocrite and a despicable father to demean his son's proactive business mind. He transferred his internal sense of failure onto his son and used the war as a convenient inflection point.

For the record, Caleb blaming himself for his brother's death in the war is completely and utterly isolated from this business transaction. He didn't send the Zimmerman Telegram or down American shipping in the open seas - the true causes of America joining the war effort. Him buying beans had absolutely nothing to do with it.

— 0