RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/television • … • u/screen_stack

Carrie S01E02 | "FOREIGN LANGUAGE"

Carrie · S01E02 · FOREIGN LANGUAGE Rating: 9.5/10 Watched: October 13, 2026

I could talk about Samantha Sloyan and her portrayal of Margaret White until the cows come home, but I chose the clip for that instead. If this sub doesn't allow clips, the scene is a pitch-perfect portrayal of gaslighting in its most insidious form: parental care and concern. The irony in what she says to Carrie is *painful*. One minute she's talking about places like that want to tell Carrie how to think, and in the very next breath, *she's telling Carrie what to think*.

I could talk about Alison Thornton as Chris Hargensen all day long. Even here in episode 2, we see not just a 'mean privileged white girl', but an absolutely broken, tragic young woman whose whole entire life is totally unraveled and *still unraveling around her*. It's a testament to the truth of life; we can never know what the other person is going through, and sometimes, what they're going through is so brutal *we* would crumble.

I could talk about my absolute *love* of Amber Midthunder in anything she does, or my stupid happiness at seeing Tahmoh Penikett in anything as well. I love both of these actors so much that it's just great seeing them anywhere.

What I really want to talk about is Tim Bagley as Mr. Morton. His scene(s) with Carrie, first in his office and then later in the library are the best kind of excellent. Truth be told, it was all so well-acted that it made me kind of sad; I was a kid 'like' Carrie in that I was weird, and awkward and most definitely undiagnosed on the spectrum somewhere. But the language for the many shades of spectrum didn't exist in the 80s and neither did school counselors where I grew up.

So watching this kind, gentle adult navigate a conversation with a young woman who has *no clue* about the real world, who has *no outlet* for her grief and dreadful feelings of being alone hit me like a telekinetic freight train. Tim's soft-spoken care and kindness, the exchange of book quotes, his introduction of the small library that was bigger than anything Carrie could've imagined was *so* well done it was magical.

I've *never* said this before because I think award shows are silly, but I genuinely want Tim Bagley to win an Emmy for his role, and for this scene in particular.

The only reason I didn't give ***Foreign Language*** an outright 10/10 is because I'm hedging my bets. I don't want to be the guy who drops 10s willy nilly, but I'll be honest.

This is a 10 in my heart, and I really hope each episode is close to it.

— 0