RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/teslamotors • … • u/trengilly

'Phantom' Braking Field Test

Having owned a Model 3 for nearly three years now with autopilot and FSD, I’ve experienced my fair share of ‘phantom’ braking. Or ‘excessive’ braking as I prefer to call it, since the reason for the braking is almost always obvious. The car is just being overly cautious about something it’s not certain about.

Whenever the car brakes, I always try to check the rear-view mirror to see if anyone is at risk of rear ending me. And in all this time I’ve never seen a car behind that was so close as to be a danger.

My hypothesis was that Autopilot/FSD is smart enough to know when a car is behind us and to not brake to cause a collision. But I haven’t had the opportunity to actually test this until today.

I have a freeway exit on the way home from work where Autopilot ALWAYS makes an excessively hard brake as it goes through an underpass and into a turn. The shadow of the underpass and upcoming turn causes it to overreact.

Today there was an idiot tailgating me as we went into the exit. He was less than a car length off my bumper. I took a deep breath and let my Tesla do its thing.

No hard braking! Autopilot actually took the exit turn faster than it ever has before and then ever so gradually slowed its approach to the eventual traffic light.

I’m totally convinced that Autopilot knew the car was tailgating me, knew braking would be dangerous, and adjusted its behavior to compensate.

FSD does do wonky things and make mistakes (and to a lesser extent so does Autopilot). But I feel they don’t get nearly as much credit as they deserve, and are generally underestimated by their critics.

— 0