Opinion: a length of 10'000 years (at the very least) would have been much more appropriate for the Merethic Era than 2500 years
The density of events in that Era just isn't consistent with 2500 years. In that Era the Aldmer ~~went from being primitive tribes to technologically advanced in Aldmeris than emigrating and colonizing~~ emigrated to and colonized all of Tamriel differentiating themselves into multiple different species. But individual Mers live for centuries... Is 2500 years enough for the Mer to evolve into a different species?
Plus it feels a little weird that Akatosh wanted to end the Kalpa after just 2000 years or so with Alduin...
**EDIT:** I was wrong initially, at the start of the Merethic Era the Aldmer lost Aldmeris and started to emigrate. Still, 2500 years doesn't add up anyway for how long the Elves live.