“Genuine question: who is ABC’s target audience now?”
I was genuinely surprised by ABC’s choice for the next Bachelorette, as it feels like a notable departure from the show’s longstanding identity. Historically, the franchise has centered around the “girl next door” archetype — individuals who embody a polished, conventionally relatable image, often reminiscent of former cheerleaders or pageant participants. Whether one appreciates that formula or not, it has undeniably been a consistent part of the show’s appeal.
This shift makes me particularly curious about ABC’s underlying market research and strategic direction. The Bachelorette has traditionally occupied a specific cultural space — something watched by sorority sisters as a form of social bonding, or faithfully followed by older generations who appreciate its familiarity and structure. It has long maintained a clear tone and audience.
At the same time, there is no shortage of genuinely kind, compelling individuals with meaningful life stories who could bring depth and freshness to the role without completely redefining the show’s identity. It would be refreshing to see the franchise highlight someone who has overcome significant life challenges, or to expand representation in a more intentional and thoughtful manner — for instance, featuring a lead with a disability or a truly unique personal journey.
As it stands, this decision feels less like a deliberate evolution and more like a shift driven by novelty. I can’t help but wonder what vision ABC has for the future of the franchise, and whether this direction aligns with the audience that has supported it for so long.