RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thebeachboys • … • u/m_dub03

My Review of Smiley Smile

Now, I love the Beach Boys and I'm no way bashing these songs. I'm just merely reviewing from a listeners perspective. Please enjoy :)

Heroes And Villains: Great song. Even my favorite Beach Boys song they did but missing the Cantina part is really bothering me

Vegetables: It's not a bad version, probably at par with the SMiLE version

Fall Break and Back to Winter: Not as good as Mrs. O'Leary's Cow

She's Going Bald: I do not,for the life of me, like it all. I really can't get behind it

Little Pad: It's not bad for a lo-fi feel to it. The laughing kind of just doesn't get it for me, but the rest of it also gives it a oldies time feel to it with the ukulele

Good Vibrations: The best song on the album cause nothing was messed with

With Me Tonight: The vocals are very impressive but it sounds so unfinished, I would love to hear a whole a backing track with a rhythm section and such

Wind Chimes: Good song but SMiLE has the better version. It's a very interesting take of it though

Gettin' Hungry: It might just be me, but it's too artsy for me but it's interesting to listen to.

Wonderful: (See Wind Chimes)

Whistle In: ????

Overall: This album just sounds so unfinished, although it is understandable why cause of the cancelation of SMiLE, but having it be so stripped back kind of loses the joy of listening to it. Now, it is a good album but nothing I would tell everyone to go listen to. Definitely 3 steps down from Pet Sounds (which you can't even come close to at all) Heroes And Villains, Good Vibrations, Little Pad and With Me Tonight are definitely the highlights of the album.

6/10

Wild Honey will be soon

— 0