RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thebulwark • … • u/mrtwidlywinks

The Problem is Communication

This was a comment but a post seems more appropriate. The communication is the real problem here, it's always been a weakness for Democrats and frankly I don’t know how they'll fix it except with new blood.

1) If the compromise Dems came out today and said "we tried to help, but it's now too late, the GOP is forcing your premiums to rise to pay for tax cuts", *that's* a message their base could get behind.

2) From a cold-blooded political calculation, getting the GOP to show their ass with regard to SNAP and health insurance premiums was an absolute win. Also this shutdown could put high premiums front of mind for the next election if the dems can drive that message (big "if" due to 1) )

Instead, the democrats are getting the worst of both worlds. They're doing the opposite of 1) and undermining 2), saying "this is the only way" "fighting Trump on this is a bad idea", and acting like their votes were a given from the start, that they don’t hold any actual power and never did. That kind of cowardice absolutely turns their base away. They must see it and not care, or are completely out of touch with their base. Or they're stupid, I don’t like false binary choices.

Pundits are warning against Democrats turning on each other, but fuck it we have a YEAR until midterms. Ousting phony representatives of our values from leadership, like Schumer, is a great first step towards a coalition of earnest voters who want real change in the health care system and don’t give a damn about "norms of a functioning of government" in the era of Trump.

I want democrats who will push *right back* on the boundaries of power Trump and the GOP are violating and I want Americans to suffer the consequences of electing Trump and the GOP. I'm traveling around Thanksgiving and a huge disruption of life is something the American people wont forget (for a few weeks). I want the suffering not because I have a hatred for the Americans who elected Trump (I do), but because being nice and protecting everyone from the consequences of electing republicans hasn’t taught them not to repeat that mistake.

I don’t think ending the shutdown is a bad idea, not messaging effectively to the base is the real failure. Treat us with the modicum of respect you give your GOP colleges in the Senate, at the very least, not like children throwing a tantrum. Build a narrative we can get behind, or the base will build one against you.

— 0