RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thebulwark • … • u/NewKojak

An argument against Sarah's America vs. Trump First heuristic

I really like that Sarah comes up with arguable frameworks and schema when she talks about politics. When most pundits do it, it's a dumb stab at setting a narrative that they can claim credit for. Sarah uses them to understand situations and dig deeper.

The other cool thing though is that you can disagree, in hopefully an interesting way that also reveals things about people. So... **this is a counterpoint to Sarah's formulation of a schism between Trumpy interventionist domination-driven Trump First Republicans and more broadly chaotic Christian identity-driven America First Republicans**.

**A schism does not matter because they are all still in the cult and competing for the affections of its leader**. I think it makes sense in the whole world of primary campaign "lanes" to think of the main appeal that different candidates and media personalities center their personalities on, but is there any sign that they would ever turn on Trump, or the leader that they ultimately coalesce around?

**These people are animated more by white chauvinistic white supremacy than policy disagreement, even about war**. There is a stronger ideological set of priorities that bind all of these people together. Similar with nobody stepping out of line on Trump, can you imagine someone differentiating themselves by being more tolerant or egalitarian? They have their story straight and nobody is singing in a different key.

**The money all comes from the same source.** A Republican leader toppling and/or meddling in another country for the purposes of resource extraction is a tale as old as the atomic bomb. There might be some new tech bro players in the scene playing the part of the Savings and Loan/Jack Abramoff/Conrad Black new money scam that we can always expect to pop up (that is a pun) during a Republican Administration. But the OG is always oil and minerals. These are the same people who fund all parts of the Republican Party.

**Trump 2.0: more hate and division, but not enough for anyone to lose their jobs**. Remember back in first Trump term, there was much more unity among the personalities surrounding Trump. There were people in the White House dishing on each other constantly, but there wasn't the outright wars that you see in Trump media today. However, none of these people are actually landing any blows on each other. Nobody has been fired from the cabinet. The House is stable. I think they have learned that they can play act in the attention economy to keep the bro podcasters on side with the religious fundamentalists and they can all tease hanging out with the Nazis.

All that said, none of it would have come to mind without Sarah's framework.

— 0