RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thebulwark • … • u/NewKojak

Consultant on Strategist on Pundit Violence

I was reading a dumb article [about James Carville throwing a fit](https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5963954-james-carville-leftist-democrats-midterms-criticism/) about primary results and thinking about how such little of what he talks about has anything to do with anything I care about. Then I realized how much I can't stand anything I see from David SIrota and Briahna Joy Gray and how much Lis Smith is awful.

Graham Platner is a great example. We get to hear all about the evils of the consultants who propped up his campaign after a whole host of other consultants and strategists cleared the field early for the corpse of Janet Mills.

These people all deserve one another. Is it any surprise that a bunch of self-interested contractors have failed at the prisoners' dilemma?

Their dumb little fights with one another have really infected the rest of the chattering ecosystem as well. A few candidates in New York have a good night and all of the sudden there are twelve heady think pieces across The Atlantic and New York Magazine trying to baby Democratic voters in the suburbs.

Is there a single strategist or consultant worth listening to?

I know that political news and opinion outlets have to grind in the attention mills all day long, but what on Earth is someone the position to make money off a political campaign going to tell me that is going to clarify a single thing?

There needs to be a cooling off period of 6 years minimum for anyone who has contracted in a federal campaign for all media appearances and op-ed writing. They can go write their dumb memoirs about how much they sucked up to powerful people all they want, but I can categorically say that they give only self-interested takes and time spent on them is better spent on either journalists, candidates, or activists.

— 0