RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thebulwark • … • u/raptoricus

Focus Group: Hurricane Helene Response

The first thing I thought when listening to that woman talk today in the podcast was "Wasn't Hurricane Helene where FEMA had to stop helping because of local militias?" The answer is "yes, to an extent".

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/oct/14/north-carolina-hurricane-helene-fema-armed-militia-threat

https://apnews.com/article/fema-north-carolina-disinformation-threats-militia-c1595fef596d0f78638ba4177bfa76af

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/fema-crews-relocate-reported-threats-armed-militia-hurricane-helene-relief/

From the third link (after an arrest was made):

> Out of an abundance of caution, FEMA said its disaster assistance teams were being stationed at fixed locations instead of going door-to-door, which has been the agency's common practice in the past.

I'm sure that really reduced the visibility of FEMA's response (e.g. there's no roads or power; how are the locals supposed to know to go to the aid station?

_____

Also, as far as the "why weren't we warned?" thread of discussion, this is unfortunately a common refrain after natural disasters. Here's a good story that also gives a chronology of the warnings: https://www.propublica.org/article/hurricane-helene-evacuation-warnings-yancey-county-north-carolina

tl;dr:

* NWS put out plenty of warnings, e.g. "This will be one of the most significant weather events of the area in the modern era" [on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/NWSGSP/posts/pfbid0GkYCwtugC5ji2wS78dc91wV7o2BvA27TB3s8KcRbeiZpFvBni7ybB3WZ5VAtMWUql#) * In NC, the local EM is who makes evacuation decisions. The EM was worried about political backlash from putting out an evacuation order (which, I'm sorry, is pretty stupid when both risk and confidence are this high) and so did not issue one. * The article doesn't mention Cooper, though he did [declare a state of emergency before the storm hit](https://governor.nc.gov/news/press-releases/2024/09/25/governor-cooper-declares-state-emergency-ahead-hurricane-helene)

The article also makes clear the scale of the devastation of Helene in that part of NC; the woman in the Focus Group who frustrated me is probably genuinely traumatized still by it. It's monstrous that the GOP is trying to politicize it (e.g. putting out [a farcical report](https://www.dhs.gov/news/2026/08/27/dhs-report-exposes-biden-era-fema-denied-aid-trump-supporters) about Biden supposedly politicizing Helene disaster aid but now "Under the Trump Administration, disaster aid is no longer politicized") and I'm frustrated that it seems to be working.

_____

All that to say... this post is probably kind of pointless -- the woman who swayed the whole focus group isn't a Bulwark subreddit browser, but I think the truth is worth remembering.

— 0