RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thedavidpakmanshow • … • u/Veda_OuO

Why Do Republicans Seemingly Vote Against Their Own Interests?

It's a very difficult question to answer. David has recently spoken of the cult-like aspects of Republican behavior, however, I don't think this captures the entire story. So why is it that, when it comes to welfare programs, healthcare access, infrastructure, community development (parks, museums, tourist attractions), education, global warming, workers' rights, tax policy, social services, etc., Republicans consistently torpedo a smorgasbord of programs from which the majority of them would directly benefit?

​

The topic has been on my mind since finishing the book, 'Strangers In Their Own Land', in which the author sought to answer this very question. She moved from Berkley to southern Louisiana - one of the most polluted, poor, sickly, federally-dependent, and right-leaning places in the country. She sought an answer to this paradox, and, after five years, came up with a theory. I'd like to know if you agree with her findings, as well as any other theories to which you're partial.

​

The author explains her theory through what she calls a "deep story". A metaphorical device she uses to convey the emotional core - and this focus on emotion turns out to be key - of what drives Republican politics. After developing this story, the people she interviewed enthusiastically agreed that it captured their feelings in an accurate way.

The story goes like this:

"You are patiently waiting in a line leading up a hill, as in a pilgrimage. You are situated in the middle of this line, along with others who are also white, older, Christian, and predominantly male, some with college degrees, some not.

Just over the brow of the hill is the American Dream, the goal of everyone waiting in line. Many in the back of the line are people of color -- poor, young and old, mainly without college degrees. It's scary to look back; there are so many behind you, and in principle you wish them well. Still, you've waited a long time, worked hard, and the line is barely moving. You deserve to move forward a little faster. You're patient but weary. You focus ahead, especially on those at the very top of the hill.

The American Dream is a dream of progress -- the idea that you're better off than your forebears just as they superseded their parents before you -- and extends beyond money and stuff...

The sun is hot and the line unmoving. In fact, is it moving backward? You haven't gotten a raise in years, and there is no talk of one. Actually. if you are short a high school diploma, or even a BA, your income has dropped over the last twenty years...

Look! You see people *cutting in line ahead of you*! You're following the rules. They aren't. As they cut in, it feels like you are being moved back. How can they just do that? Who are they?"

​

The author goes on to describe all the groups which have been the beneficiaries of "liberal sympathy" (women, people of color, immigrants, refugees, public sector workers, etc.) who are now taking advantage of opportunities which they had not been offered in the past. This "line cutting" further compounds Conservative frustrations with their stagnating wages as they see their prospects of achieving the American Dream slip away.

The liberal catcalls of "Crazy redneck.", "White trash.", "Bible-thumper", and "Ignorant Hillbilly" couple this latent frustration with an intense shame. In the final section of the story, the author describes how Conservatives feel that Liberal morality - through Hollywood, news media, and popular television - is being pushed on them at the same time their spots in line are being unfairly rearranged.

​

So, how does this story answer the question I posed to you?

I think it describes a weary, exploited, and pissed off person who has worked their entire life truly believing that, if they just stick with the program and color between the lines, they are destined for wealth and respect.

The US is a two-party system; to whom would someone like this give their vote? According to the theory, the Democrats are the ones who are aiding the line-cutters, propping up a corrupt federal government (a foremost and universal belief of those in the book), and radically imperializing the moral fabric of your beloved community.

This scenario leaves such a person with the Republicans. The book stops short of giving a super satisfactory answer to why the Republican platform looks the way it does. Why allow pollution to destroy public waters and private land? The answer given by the interviewees was *always* "jobs". Without the oil and chemical companies, they felt they had no path to the American Dream. However, the author makes an extremely good point that those same oil jobs came at the expense of tourist jobs, tens of thousands of fishing jobs, and prospective clean industry which otherwise would have considered investing in the healthy, thriving Louisiana communities which could have been.

TLDR:

Put simply, I think the Republican machine expertly harnesses this anger to the benefit of it's donors (the rich). The blue collar conservative is allowed to believe in the fairy tale of the American Dream, that their place in line will be preserved, their moral worldview restored, and their reputation reclaimed if they tow the party line and turn out to vote.

I also think many Republicans realize that some of the policies for which they vote actively hurt them. For example, those interviewed *knew* voting Republican meant allowing pollution to swallow the world around them - and every person in the book knew many people who had died early deaths to rare forms of cancer; one lost his home to a sinkhole caused by salt mining, others had their ancestral lands literally devoured and purged by chemicals dumped upstream from their properties.

The Republican party does offer small wins to people like this. The MTG's and Lauren Boeberts of the world do actually go to bat for them when it comes to social issues and cracking down on the line cutting. I think, in their minds, to allow affirmative action and welfare programs is to incalculably shift the order of the line. I don't think it's clear to anyone just how the new line will sort itself out. So why would they ever consent to a shuffle when they've held such a favorable position for so long a time?

​

Like David's cult perspective, I think this theory is important but doesn't necessarily account for the entire state of affairs. What do you think?

— 0