CNN - How are they not justified?
Firstly, as I have made the mistake before here of not doing this, please let me say to start with that I am not a fan of CNN, don't watch them and I think their news division is a joke. I also agree that the form and structure of these televised debates is more about creating conflict that helping weed out bad ideas and candidates, or at least clarifying what everyone believes. But I am confused as to why people feel David is entitled to use the CNN broadcast, I am open to having my mind changed on this, I wonder if I have just not seen the information in the right light?
But, I am really at a loss trying to understand the vitriol on this page about the action taken against DP during the second debate. People have raised, in various ways, two main reasons they feel DP was justified in using the CNN stream. "Fair Use" and "Public Interest".
The public interest argument is something I agree with, but in that the entire system needs to be realigned to be publicly owned from the ground up. Either way, the desire for a different system of broadcast ownership of debates doesn't change the current reality. It also ignores that the debate was still free to air and accessible by anyone who wanted to see it, so the public in no way is denied access just because DP can't stream it. And DP's views are not censored as he is still free to broadcast any thoughts he has on the debate.
The fair use argument seems even more problematic. I worked in broadcasting but perhaps my understanding of fair use is out of date or I am applying this wrong. My understanding of fair use is that there are no fixed standards as such but there are four general areas that get examined in each case, transformation, parody, totality of use and market impact. I don't see that adding a commentary track meets the standard of fair use. If it did we would see Fox with a stream doing what DP was doing, we would see people co-opting sports events with their own commentary. Simply talking over it does not change the core appeal of the content, which as most here seem to agree was to watch candidates debate and get a sense of who they were. It obviously isn't parody so we can ignore that. It would have used pretty much the entire debate so it's impossible to argue that he wasn't using the totality of the content so that is also a non starter. Market impact is probably a harder one for CNN to show, but as DP has so many subscribers, followers and live stream viewers I would think it enough to make the argument, perhaps not with DP specifically, but in the sense that if they allow this in general and don't start shutting it down they could look at very real losses in potential income.
I guess I am just not sure I see why people feel CNN is so evil empire with this. Please feel free to point out what I am missing here. Again, I am not saying I think the current system is the way to go, but it is the system we have so the current rules and laws apply.