RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thedavidpakmanshow • … • u/Moutere_Boy

Joe Manchin steel man question

DP had a section at the top of his show about Manchin and his response to the Capitol building riots.

To be clear, I’m not supporting his view as much as I’m thinking David may have washed over a reasonable response without actually considering it.

I don’t think Manchin is entirely wrong in saying that the riots shocked him and have him pause. I also don’t think that it’s entirely wrong to use that opportunity to look at the broader picture. If people were willing to do this, at least in part because they feel disenfranchised and ignored, isn’t listening to them at least worth the time? If a Republican had come out during the BLM riots and said that they deplore the violence but it had also shocked them into realising how desperate the situation is for some people that they have been driven to these lengths and they wanted to engage, see how they as a community leader could help or effect the situation, wouldn’t we commend that? I certainly don’t think we would accuse them of bowing to violent demands would we?

I know that analogy is fairly loaded after all the rubbish and clearly disingenuous “what about BLM” comments from the right, and I don’t think we can compare the validity of why the BLM riots happen against the Jan 6, but I’m talking about the response to the action rather than the action itself.

I’m really curious if anyone feels the same?

— 0