RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thedavidpakmanshow • … • u/Veda_OuO

How would you define "woman"?

I was watching David's recent appearance on the Daily Wire and was surprised when the question oozed from Michael Knowle's jagged grin. Not because it's some new issue I'd never considered, but because I didn't have a solid answer.

Being the sophisticated researcher I am, I headed over to [dictionary.com](https://dictionary.com), searched "woman", and found something interesting: "an adult female person".

This of course gets us no where if we aren't familiar with their working definition of "female": a person bearing two X chromosomes in the cell nuclei and normally having a vagina, a uterus and ovaries, and developing at puberty a relatively rounded body and enlarged breasts, and retaining a beardless face; a girl or woman

So, as of this moment, it's clear that [dictionary.com](https://dictionary.com)'s definition (as well as Merriam Webster's, and Britannica's) appeals strictly to a person's sexual characteristics, typically determined in utero by their chromosomes.

Yes, I realize appealing to a dictionary is a brutish way to approach the topic, **BUT**, this is *precisel*y how I would expect someone like Michael to define the word. So, I'm wondering what a more sophisticated definition of "woman" would look like; one that captures the very real concerns of the transgender community and modern gender theory on the whole.

There are some interesting questions one must ask when considering the definition:

* What role, if any, should "sex" play? * Is someone's gender identity (internally held belief about their gender) sufficient to warrant a categorization... * Or, must this belief be expressed externally to be sufficient? * How important are aesthetics (mannerisms, dress, features, preferences, etc.)

Conservative thinking seems to gatekeep womanhood by demanding that all women have XX sexual traits while ignoring any additional criteria. The biggest downside to this approach is that it just lacks real-world, applied utility - it fails to capture current thinking on the issue and does not cohere with the living use of the word.

What is your definition of woman? Do you think such a definition exists that would satisfy both a conservative's view of a woman and a progressive's view of a woman?

​

​

Context: [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dwOSlwtyA\_M](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dwOSlwtyA_M)

— 0