Oakstar's Dynasty
So I was poking around the Wiki recently and had a revelation: Oakstar has a 5 generation dynasty going on, with two of his direct descendants being current leaders. Oakstar was leader himself, and his son also became leader, Pinestar. He of course fathered Tigerstar 1.0, who in turn fathered Bramble and Tawny. The former of the two became the leader of his generation, while Tawnypelt gave birth to Tigerstar 2.0, the leader of the fifth generation. For being such a mediocre leader, he sure had some persistent genes!