Make tanking in the game viable
As everyone notices, the game is lacking a tank class and tanking is not properly working in group play.
Division was planned as a cover shooter, but with enemies rushing at you and lobbing deadly grenades over huge distances, staying in cover is not really viable. In most circumstances it's better to bring more DPS and it's a lot easier to spec for it. Other games have the concept of tanks.
The job of the tank is two fold (how tanking works in other games):
1. Reduce incoming damage in a meaningful way, so healer can heal more efficiently 2. Take aggro - make sure the enemy targets the tank. (so healers have to heal only a single target)
The first one cannot be done in the moment, except in countdown and the new master difficulty, as there are too many red and violet enemies that don't work with PFE. The amount of damage reduction provided by aegis and provocateur is not enough (more on that later)
The second one... Mosquito is not a viable solution for taking aggro on a whole encounter. It's just not working. We don't have any other tool for aggro control, but we have the mechanics in the game, so there is hope.
The proposed changes:
1. Either make PFE mods a plain damage reduction mod. (same amount) or add a plain 10% damage reduction to each blue core (so we end up with 60% all blue build) (or both changes, doesn't hurt) Damage reduction of blue cores doesn't have to work in PVP, I don't play it that much, but every peace equipment has their own rules there anyways.
The math behind tanking: (that applies already to PFE builds)
Incoming damage reduction vs. survivability vs increase of survivability\*\*\*
10% -- 111% -- 11.1% 20% -- 125% -- 13.9% 30% -- 142% -- 17.8% 40% -- 166,6% -- 23.8% 50% -- 200% -- 33.3% 60% -- 250% -- 50% 66% -- 300% -- 53% 70% -- 333% -- 30.3% (83.3% compared to 60%) 80% -- 500% -- 166% 90% -- 1000% (not possible, as it caps out at 80%, only to show how ridicules it becomes)
survivability as in how much damage it takes to kill you and how much more effectively healing would be.
As anyone can see in the above table, going from 0-50% does make as big of an difference in effective HP as going from 60-80%. The last 10% to 80% do as much as difference as the first 40%.
So if we have 60% from six 6 blue cores and add another 20% from AEGIS, we are actually tanky to survive them. (if we can could keep aggro). From 0-20 does nothing and that's why the set it not useful, even with the new chest piece. It would give is an effective HP pool of 166% which is not enough to survive the aggro of an whole encounter.
2. Add an aggro pulse skill that scales of blue cores (like shields) so we can keep aggro away from the team mates. We have the aggro skill on Mosquito, so we only need that as a pulse, so we get reliably targeted, so other team mates can take them out without dying. The skill should not forceable make the enemies targeting you, but increase your threat towards them --> You have to stay active to be a threat and Mosquito is not useless and the situation stays dynamic.
Another possible way would be a plain aggro-increase of 15-20% per blue core, so you don't have to waste a skill slot.
\*\*\* This table also applies now to PFE, so take it to explain to your friends why the last few percent of PFE are so important and they shouldn't stop at 70% (if they insist on having an PFE built)
edit: When you add 10% DR on blue cores and consider to convert PFE mods to DR, their value should be halved for balancing reason. So it's not too easy to get full DR without mods only, but they stay useful to optimize the build.