RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thedivision • … • u/Archmage_Drenden

"Wall of Text" On The State of End-Game and How It Might Be Improved

I have been playing the division almost nonstop since release and I have loved almost every moment, from the jaw-dropping graphics to the multi-faceted story line. I am, however, a bit underwhelmed with the economy for players looking to get the most out of the game. First, I’ll lay out exactly what I see on my current character.

- I have all high end gear with stats that somewhat work with what I want to achieve in my build, except for a superior chest, holster, and various mods. - As of writing I have 521,096 credits, 92717 DZ funds, and 118 phoenix credits. - 5 out of 6 of my high end items I have the blueprints for. - All of my crafting materials have been upgraded to superior quality and are converted as needed to high end. -I have completed all side missions and encounters.

With what I have, I feel that I am under-utilizing credits and DZ funds but I am pouring out phoenix credits. When I check vendors on reset, it’s either to see if there’s a better roll on a mod from the dark zone vendor or I’m buying a new weapon skin from the appearance vendor. I have seen the vendors within the Dark Zone and I have little urge to purchase anything from them.

In the way of play, I solo all my hard-mode dailies with ease. I group for the challenge missions mostly for aggro swapping but I believe it is also do-able solo. I roam the streets that I use to own wondering what all this space is going to be used for in the days to come.

I believe several solutions are mostly definitely viable but here are my thoughts on improving our experience.

---Phoenix Funds stay near the low rate they are at now---

Although I believe three phoenix credits for a boss might be too low, I have been able to grind credits like mad and buy 5 blueprints as well as afford a couple recalibrations. And this is with only doing the dailies a few times plus the days I have been max level to farm bosses. The dailies, although tedious, are a great way to get people to log back on every day to appreciate this game as well as a starting point for groups to warm up for whatever activity they have planned. This comes with the added bonus of gaining an end-game currency which unlocks essentially the most powerful item for a slot on your person, given proper farming of materials. Once you get that blueprint you should be making copies of it to get the rolls you want in conjunction with the recalibration station.

---Recalibration costs regular credits or DZ funds for all items and more than one stat can be recalibrated---

For those about to experience this, prepare yourself. As of now, recalibrating a high-end item costs phoenix credits, only one stat can be chosen to be recalibrated, and every recalibration costs increasingly more phoenix credits. The base armor stat of an item can also not be recalibrated. If recalibrating is opened up to allow for many chances at the ideal build for the player, then the player will become more attached to their loot and understand more about what their build is attempting to achieve. It is also good to note that they will have the capacity to achieve those goals. By using a more farmable resource (regular credits and DZ funds) to access a system that requires a constant flow to return on its investment, we can see a world where specialization and optimization doesn’t take eons of grinding and being sent back to square one.

Although, not to stop myself short, having the ultimate freedom to recalibrate everything is just as bad as the system in place now. If we spend the time and effort to get the phoenix credits to buy the blueprint, grind the materials to craft the item, and then have access to do whatever we want to it, we no longer need that blueprint. It would make more sense to just find a vendor selling that item and recalibrate it from there.

My take on balance for this is to lock the armor and stat (firearms, stamina, electronics) to the crafting of the item. But, to stray from RNGesus taking the wheel and leaving some players with no materials for no rewards, offering the “combination” station. This will allow two items of the same quality and item slot to combine, taking the highest armor and a chosen stat bonus from each piece to make an item of the same quality and item slot. This permits even the unluckiest player to eventually gear up through sheer determination.

Say you crafted two kneepads. One has high armor and medium electronics. The other has low armor and low firearms. Through combination, you could take the high armor from the first but, since you don’t want electronics, you can put the firearms onto it. I understand that the recalibration of stats already accomplishes what I’ve proposed, but the goal here is to take all those failed attempts and generate a base that you want, not just the best one you could pump out. Combination would also have the added benefit of either keeping one item’s perks or generating a whole new set. This process would also cost credits or funds to steer away from the materials you just dumped into making the items.

---Vendors are fun for everyone---

Unless I’m mistaken, the only way to obtain a high-end chest or holster is by hitting rank 50 in the DZ and buying them from the DZ06 vendor. I like this idea as it keeps us from grinding the whole time to get numbers to spend on other numbers until we get what we want. But it does tend to suck the fun out of climbing a mountain when there’s just the bottom and the top without any steps in between.

Selling a sub-max item with limited availability for recalibration is similar to saying “Hey players that use turrets, you get an upgrade this week if you have the cash to pay. If you don’t, get back in line. And if you don’t use turrets, I hope you like the build that has all the things that people with turrets like except for that one stat for turrets that you can reroll. Otherwise, I guess you’ll just have to keep holding on to your money until the right thing shows up.” I think open recalibration and combination will allow vendors to sell items for a slot at a marginally steep price so that players gain a piece they can tinker with, while also gaining a reason to go see that vendor to buy the item or maybe hold off for something closer to what they need. And selling 2/9 pieces is probably where I’d keep it in order to maintain the recalibration system as a grounds for personalization since in this new world the stats on those two vendor-bought items will be locked more or less.

---Mod slots are available on all items and mods come from RNG drops---

I have heard through all games the praise and hate towards the Random Number Generator system. I know I have spent too much time in WoW grinding the same place over and over just for a chance to see the item I want drop. Let alone that it has the right stats or that I outroll the other people in the group that “need” it. Nowadays, the latter part is a rare thing in an MMO, but I believe The Division can take this further into the realm of the RNG. But first, let’s recap.

We’ve made it so that gear can be bought, crafted, recalibrated, or combined. Through expenditure of phoenix credits, we gain blueprints to make pieces of gear. Using regular credits or DZ funds will allow us to make that gear our own. But where then do we get weapons and mods? Well, certain mods can be made by buying blueprints for phoenix credits. And they only have two options which, to me, seems reasonable enough to exclude them from recalibration. Weapons are how numbers get put down range, so making the options listed earlier available is almost a must. However, I don’t think weapons should be crafted. At least not with random damage numbers.

The gun you craft should come with a standard damage amount and random perks. This gives way to the player’s having the gun their way, with a solid starting point for dps for player’s to gauge fights and developer’s to make the fights happen without needing bullet sponges or paper paragons. The damage of a weapon should be increased by either replacing it with a weapon out of a mission/incursion/DarkZoneSuperBadGuy, or by combining it with that gun you found so that you get to keep your gun and feel like you made progress for the day.

It’s like my grandma always says; “Feed a gun bullets, Bobby, and it’ll take down your enemies. But feed a gun more guns that shoot bullets and you got yourself a recipe for taking down even bigger foes.” Thanks, grandma. Also my name isn’t Bobby, please stop calling me that.

The exception I’d make here, though, is that a gun from a boss should feel unique. There should be a feel to it that doesn’t compare to other guns. And the perks for that gun should be locked in and ready from the start. “Ferro the Ferocious” shouldn’t drop an assault rifle since that’s not what he uses just as “Keener ain’t a cleaner” so a gear mod that pops out of him probably shouldn’t be all about adding effects to your flamethrower turret. There’s some major potential to release unique weapons and mods that tie back to the characters we first met trekking across Manhattan.

---Replay-ability is huge for maintaining a player base just as much as new content is---

As an MMO ages, new software gets released, back-end things need tweaking, systems get refined, additions are made to expand on the world player’s know to show them something exciting and fresh. But a new player can be anyone who starts now or two years from now. And the old players have no reason to go back and help the new players get up to speed.

Bungie managed rehashing some of their old encounters with the release of “The Taken King”. Unfortunately, this amounted to a 50% chance of fighting old mobs or new mobs in a given area and that’s it. I feel that an instance should have multiple “acts” that are either permanent changes to the scripting of the encounter or changes that can be played or not played to maintain the original mini-story that the area tells. This adds unfamiliar combat mechanics or characters to a once familiar scene.

Since this is only the beginning, very little of this applies right now but it’s food for thought. As it stands, newer players cannot play with the “veterans”. Anything in their world scales up to match the new threat and the one who needs the time on the front lines is left throwing rocks from base camp to get credit for the work that they aren’t doing. I think the easiest solution is just to scale down to the average level of the group, omitting the players who are more than five levels away from the mean. For those way up the totem pole, they’d receive a “buff” that changes bullet damage to percent health damage based on the weapon’s quality, type, and capacity. This should keep them from deleting low level mobs while still offering aid to the group. I’m sure there’s plenty of fringe cases with a level 10, 20, and 30 all looking to group up, but for some of those groups there may be a solution.

A recruit-a-friend system (The Third Wave?) is still some ways away to give incentives to max level players to help those just starting, but let’s say pairs grouped in this way will receive bonuses. Maybe they could gain crafting materials to help the newbie stay relevant or the oldie to work for an item they want to craft. For now, a balance change to make it possible to play with all your friends short of creating a new character would be nice.

---Rogue status is fun and rewarding---

I honestly don’t have much for here, I just think the rewards are minimal and the punishment is too great. Plus, the timer stopping for long periods of time in combat seems like it defeats the purpose of a timer. Maybe we can make gear sets and some “Darkside” Zone Funds? That way the rogues get special stuff and they are identifiable as potential rogues. And the timer is alright but perhaps a location to hold out in to lose their status may be more rewarding and feel more natural, similar to an extraction for those of us who are DOING OUR JOBS as agents to restore New York.

But instead of extracting gear they could extract themselves. This would eliminate cases like those who, let’s pretend, accidentally mark themselves rogue through crossfire but manage to kill the people around them that don’t accept apologies. Then you’re stuck as a rogue for five minutes but really it’s just Checkpoint Omega from Halo: Reach and we all know how that goes… Needless to say there’s some salt crusted on this system for me but I think it’s a very unique feature that deserves a better balance to encourage all facets of play.

That’s about all I have so if you’ve made it this far; thanks for listening. I’m having a great time with this game and I’m ready to see what the new day brings. Best of luck to you all in the Dark Zone and everything beyond!

----------------------- TL;DR: I think regular credits and DZ funds should be used for more things, the crafting system should give more control of stats over to the player, certain piece of gear should come from vendors or drops to get us off the crafting bench, rogues should have some sort of tell in a combat zone and be rewarded for doing what they do well, areas should be dynamic to keep things alive, and some aid should be given to new players from older ones to help usher them into whatever age we’re in.

— 0