Survival and why it won’t return
**tldr: Questions about setting, gameplay loop, combat, and monetization have to be ironed out before there is even a serious discussion about the next Survival experience.**
Hands down, without any rival, Survival is my favorite game mode in the Division. It is the reason I’ve stuck with the game for so long. It was through Survival I learned and got comfortable with the DZ because I would have never ventured into the DZ otherwise.
But enough about me.
There is a fear, or better yet, huge concern that Survival, at least as we know it, will not be returning in TD2. And because of the significant changes TD2 made from TD1, Survival might not even return at all. The main reasons: setting, map, combat.
Starting with the most obvious, the backdrop of a severe snowstorm was the perfect setting for TD1’s Survival. Fighting NPCs and players is something every survival-like game does on some level, TD1’s Survival added the element of the fight against the environment with the cold meter and wind conditions. Without the proper protection, your character can die from freezing, and the weather/wind conditions reinforce the gravity of that fight. Being set in summertime DC, TD2 will lack this defining characteristic of Survival. Sure, it can be too hot. So, shade and a bottle of water? And what of the weather? Just a bright sunny day in DC? Or go the inclement weather route with thunderstorm conditions. The “fog of war” from a heavy rain would seem similar to a snow storm but would lack the player dying from freezing. A bit off topic, but would a severe thunderstorm be more taxing on system performance than a severe snow storm (assuming each option was rendered as efficiently as possible)? Either way, TD2 will lose the layered nuance of the environmental fight that TD1 provides.
Zooming out to the bigger picture, Survival’s gameplay mechanic was made for the TD1’s created map of NY. Everyone spawns as close to symmetric as possible to the central goal, get to the DZ. This worked in TD1 because the DZ was in the center of the map. With the introduction of 3 DZs in TD2, we lose that race to the center of the map. Maybe they go the route of smaller area, smaller player count. I would hope not because traversing and surviving the vastness of the NY map is part of the gameplay of Survival. Maybe they go the route of players battling to a randomly chosen DZ. I am not looking to make suggestions in this piece, just want to present the challenges in bringing Survival back for TD2. Survival is a game mode solely created around the dynamics of the TD1 NY map, without it the mode will have to be almost recreated, from scratch.
Speaking of scratch, combat in TD2 will make or break its success. That is almost fact. With that said, among the list of things well received by players of TD1 and Survival is the combat. Players from both sides, PvP and PvE, appreciate the simplicity of the early game pistol fight and the end-game resources “war of arms”, sort of say. There are no signature skills and TTK is low relative to the base game. All of this has been addressed in TD2, seemingly. Though, with all we have seen, the new combat system appears to be the most unsure direction the devs have taken. Survival released well into TD1’s life cycle. After a certain “combat stability” was reached. Right now, no one has played with or against a high end optimized build. Questions about movement and outplaying your opponent still linger, as well. This all must be figured out before introducing a game mode as complex as Survival.
If released for TD2, it would obviously be free for the entire player base. Does that increase its chances for success? Was the TD1 version of Survival successful financially, given the split it caused in the player base? Is it even worth creating from scratch, again given the industry’s monetization “needs”? Questions about setting, gameplay loop, combat, and monetization have to be ironed out before there is even a serious discussion about the next Survival experience. It is my personal belief that those discussions have yet to happen given the complexity of the subject matter and the studio’s focus on base game content (there is a lot of that, to be fair).
Thank you for reading all the way through (if you have). Happy to expound on any discussion points listed above. This is my longest reddit post to date. I believe, given the road map for content and monetization released so far, Survival, if it was 100% coming back, would have had more of a mention. “We would like to see it back” is not a mention. What do you think?