RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thedivision • … • u/elberto83

Core attributes and the problem with random rolls

**Warning:**

Wall of text incoming, TL:DR at the bottom of the post.

​

# Introduction

When TU8 started, most of us were leveling and shooting our way through New York. And during that time, many of you, just like me, have probably started to fill our Recalibration Library. And there's something odd that you may not have noticed right away. When it comes to the Core Attributes, one of those is not like the others. Can you guess which one? I'll give you a hint: How many times have you extracted Weapon Damage or Armor from a piece of gear, just to get closer to the maximum? And how many times did you do that with Skill Tier? Exactly. Once per slot.

​

# The inequality of core attributes

Skill Tier is, from an optimization perspective, the BEST of the three core attributes. The reason for this is simple: it has no minimum value. While Weapon Damage and Armor can vary from terribly low to acceptable or even perfect, Skill Tier can not. It has no random values.

Set items "suffer" from a similar problem: They have only two attributes (including the core attribute), therefore it's easier to find a well rolled one.

The Hardwired set is the pinnacle of this inequality between core and random attributes. Since those pieces have only one random attribute, it's practially impossible to get a "bad" one. You can just recalibrate the random attribute and BOOM. God roll.

​

The problem with the current gear system is not randomness in itself. It is the "amount of randomness", the total number of random attributes. Let's have a look at the following example:

* Item 1 is a holster with 7% Weapon Damage, 12% Critical Hit Damage and 3% Critical Hit chance. 2 low attributes, 1 maxed. You'll probably end up dismantling or selling it. * Item 2 is a holster with Skill Tier, 17% Repair skill and... Health. You can recalibrate the latter to skill haste and use it for a healer build. It may not be perfect, but close enough to last for a while.

The result of this is that it's actually easier to create good Skill Tier based gear pieces. The core attribute is already maxed, you only need one random attribute that fits your desired build. It doesn't even have to be maxed, just high enough.

At the same time, getting good pieces with Armor/Weapon Damage is actually more difficult, since all three attributes depend on luck, and all of this doesn't even take the color of random attributes into account.

​

# Proposals for a solution

I see two possible ways of solving this problem: even the odds or reducing the variance.

**Even the odds:**

\- Add bars for Armor and Weapon Damage similar to the already existing one for Skill Tier.

\- Have each point of those core attributes provide a fixed value.

​

**Reducing the variance:**

\- Increase the minimum value for Armor and Weapon Damage, e.g. to 10% for Weapon Damage

\- This would result in a higher average value, making it easier to focus on the other two attributes to get a usable piece of gear.

​

Although the first solution might be the obvious choice, I personally would prefer the second one. The reason is simple: It would still allow room for optimization. There could still be a better item, allowing you to squeeze just a tiny bit more dps out of your build, you just haven't found it yet.

​

Thanks for reading.

# TL:DR

* Skill Tier is, from an optimization perspective, the best core attribute * Weapon Damage and Armor suffer from their high variance between minimum and maximum, therefore making it more difficult to find good gear pieces * Either have Armor and Weapon Damage provide fixed increases OR * Increase the minimum value, thus reducing the variance

— 0