RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/theology • … • u/Professional_Fix8512

An argument for general theism/against the atheistic multiverse point against fine tuning

AI disclaimer, ChatGPT used to battle my point/summarize into what you’ll be reading. However this points is from myself/taken from human sources

The universe operates under highly precise physical laws and constants that appear finely tuned for life. While a multiverse is often proposed to explain this, it still depends on an underlying framework of physical laws that determine what kinds of universes are possible. This means the multiverse does not ultimately explain fine-tuning, but shifts the question to why those deeper laws exist at all. Even if those laws are claimed to be necessary, that does not explain why that necessity exists rather than something else or nothing. Therefore, a necessary foundation of reality is required, and a necessary mind provides a more complete explanation than impersonal laws. This mind is, what theism identifies as God.

For those of us who don’t want to read:

The multiverse proposition is not a sufficient argument against fine tuning as that multiverse would be under also similarly precise laws to allow for these universes. Therefore the point is just shifted instead of explained. Additionally, stating a law is how it is because of necessity is not a sufficient justification of why that law works the way it does; it needs explanation

— 0