RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/theouterworlds • … • u/LurkerOnTheInternet

Brief guide to melee (1H vs 2H, sneak vs non-sneak)

First I'll summarize: high-sneak characters should use one-handed weapons for open combat, but ideally two-handed for sneak attacks (though one-handed is fine). Non-sneak characters should always use two-handed weapons.

1H weapons do roughly 1/3, or even less, of the damage of 2H weapons, though with 1.8 attacks/second as opposed to 1.1. This means their innate damage, including DPS, is much worse. And the innate +250% sneak attack bonus is nowhere near enough to make up for that.

However, *Vital Strikes* changes things completely. This perk requires 15 Melee and 15 Sneak, and adds 50% of your sneak-attack to all non-sneak melee attacks with 1H weapons. This is absurdly powerful.

Some math: the best 1H weapons have a base damage of either 31 or 36. Most of the best 2H weapons have a base damage of 110. With Melee 20 and Sneak 15, Treacherous and Vital Strikes, the damage becomes:

1H: 93 or 108 base with +975% sneak attack (1000 or 1161 sneak-attack damage)

2H: 330 base with +625% sneak (2393 sneak-attack damage)

However, with Vital Strikes, the actual 1H damage per hit would be **546 or 635**, vs 330. Almost twice as much. And the actual DPS would be **983 or 1142**, vs 363. **3x as much!** (Note that this excludes unique-item effects.)

I can confirm, from doing a melee playthrough, that 1H weapons did indeed do significantly more damage than 2H, including Wham-Bam, in open combat. That said, some perks like Echoing Blows and Run and Hitter have a greater effect for 2H weapons, and certainly they are perfectly strong in open combat, but 1H is more effective as long as you have 15+ Sneak and take Vital Strikes.

Of course it must be mentioned that there is a helmet that adds 10% of your sneak-attack bonus to melee attacks. With that, the math becomes:

1H: 637 or 740 per hit (1147 or 1332 DPS)

2H: 536 per hit (590 DPS)

A big benefit to 2H weapons in particular, if you have high Sneak, but 1H still does more damage, especially in DPS.

In summary, use whatever weapons you want if you have Sneak 15+, though 1H is optimal, but non-sneak should always stick with 2H weapons.

— 0