Just finished Toxicity. Here are my thoughts.
I just finished my first complete new-start playthrough of Toxicity. Here are my thoughts.
Overall, the DLC was fun. The new map was a joy to discover – probably the best part of the game. It was very large and expansive, and quite vertical. There were a few new ideas on display, some of which give me some thoughts on where the franchise will go next. Lots of new structures to explore, new loot to discover, and new golden chests to loot – a feature that was missing from the Moons update. Glad to see the secret chests returned to the game!
The new mechanic was interesting. It added new challenges to an established game, and changed how the players thought about achieving their goals. There was a lot of variety in the mechanic, new items and builds, finds and unlocks, and good playability. On the whole, it was a worthy addition to The Planet Crafter library.
Now for some of the quibbles.
As others have mentioned before me, the unlocks are wonky. Often times during playthrough I would find myself unlocking items out of order. Finding that I could unlock items before I had the ability to build those things. Like getting the Incubator before you have Larvae, or getting the T5 Exoskeleton chip before you get the T3 Exoskeleton chip, making it impossible to build. These aren't game-breaking issues, and The Planet Crafter has always given you the ability to build into a specific unlock as you liked, but these issues occur so regularly in Toxicity that it makes the entire game's progression seem at least mildly broken. As if the Developers rushed the final product and did not invest enough time into ensuring that the progression felt natural, as it had in the previous games in the series. Again, not a deal-breaker for sure, but small details like this break the illusion, and pull the gamer out of the fantasy.
I also felt that the main game mechanic - the whole Toxic thing, was just layered on top of the existing game, without much integration into standard gameplay. In Toxicity, you have 32 toxic areas that need to be cleaned of their toxins to achieve the endgame. You also have certain broad detoxification goals to meet. The game also requires you to clean areas of toxic water, and while cleaning that water is necessary to obtain specific materials you will need ingame, the actual toxicity of the water is irrelevant. You can reach the endgame without cleaning all of the toxic water. Likewise, you don't need to clean up all of the toxic spores, leaking radioactive containers, or random piles of junk. The actual goal of the new mechanic is very narrow, and you need to do very little to accomplish it. I would have enjoyed seeing this mechanic exploited much, much more broadly.
If you are going to require the player to do a thing, like detoxify bodies of water, have it mean something. Make it required to do for cleaning the planet, not just for materials gain. If the goal is to remove toxic elements, apply that to the whole game, and not just “enough” to satisfy your building requirements. I feel like the Toxic mechanic was just surface deep, lacking any real depth or substance. It is literally just a thin veneer of a mechanic laid on top of the standard Planet Crafter game play.
Lastly, I would have liked to see the Toxic planet situation applied in a more cohesive way. Currently, you only need to meet one Toxic metric to reach endgame. All other metrics are the same – heat, pressure, oxygen, biomass, animal life, what have you. Toxicity is all that, plus “toxic.” I would have loved to see The Planet Crafter embrace its Toxic premise more fully. Make the planet more contaminated, with, perhaps, a runaway greenhouse effect. So instead of having to bring oxygen, heat and pressure up, we need instead to bring those metrics down. Reverse the standard mechanics and have the numbers run in reverse. Replace the Heaters with Coolers, the Drills with Vents, and the Gas Extractors with Sequesters, pulling toxic gasses out of the atmosphere while bleeding off valuable gasses for game play purposes. Of course, I'm not asking for a whole new game – this would, essentially, be a reskin of the existing mechanic. But instead of numbers go up, they go down to meet a specified margin. I just feel that this would have made the “Terraformation” of this planet more inline with the conditions of the planet as presented. Instead of Terraforming Mars, where we have to build everything up, we Terraform Venus, where we have to bring everything down.
And finally, man, the endings were boring. Miju games isn't exactly renowned for its endgame sequences, but holy hell, those were some of the most underwhelming endgame scenes in the entire franchise. At least Prime and Humble gave you a feeling of accomplishing something. The endgame sequences in Toxicity were just “meh.” Very unimpressed.
On the whole, I enjoyed my time with Toxicity. As always, I am a big fan of the franchise, and look forward to what these developers release next. I probably won't return to this particular save however. I may return to terraform Toxicity again from one of my other planets, so that I can see how the gameplay differs when you have all the unlocks and resources available. Otherwise, GG!