Trying to understand Andrew's defense for the bonus star
I would like to start off by saying I'm on Andrew's side
Also, many thanks to Andrew for bringing it up during the podcast when he could have gone with Eric's plan and just never mentioned it again.
I like many others, after listening to 118 did not understand why Andrew gets away with his non-theater viewings counting for the bonus star for most summer movies watched. So let's look at this excerpt from the draft itself.
**Exhibit A - Summer Movie League 2026 Draft:**
>Eric: Do you think seeing the most summer movies from the guy who saw every summer movie last year might be tailored to one guy in specific also Geoff?
>Andrew: Guess how many I saw in theaters though *during the league*, zero, I would not have won
The "during the league" part of Andrew's sentence was muffled due to laughter from other podcast members, which I think a lot of people (including myself *and the spotify transcript*) missed. In episode 118 I do think the explanations given aren't as succinct as they could have been.
**Exhibit B - With Medium Power Comes Medium Responsibility // The Fishin Magician [118]**
>Andrew: My point was that my availability, my accessibility to seeing these films would be limited to other people that go to the theater. I wasn’t saying that watching it at home wouldn’t count. My point was that we are going to record this at the end of the summer as opposed to December like we did last time, which gave ample time for everything to be on VOD.
>[Some talk between Gavin, Geoff and Eric]
>Eric: What he is reframing from what he’s saying, which is different from what he is said, but it makes sense when he explains it, is that ‘How many did I see in the theater, zero, I would not have won because I would not have gone to see these movies if that were the case. I understand what he’s positing in that situation.
>Geoff: He’s saying if that were the requirement, I would have lost because I would gone to 0 movies.
Honestly, the input from Eric and Geoff confused me and its likely I am just completely missing how what they are saying is congruent with Andrew's point. So personally, if you are using what they said to figure out what happened, I think you should disregard it.
Back to the draft discussion. Andrew wasn't talking about a rule where it was theaters only.
**He was trying to say this:**
>I didn't watch any summer league movies during the actual summer league. I watched them on VOD after the summer league when they were in theaters. Therefore, having watched zero movies during the summer league itself, I would have gotten a zero for this bonus star, and would not have won it had it come up.
**And he shortcut that into:**
>Guess how many I saw in theaters though during the league, zero, I would not have won.
This phrasing shortcut does make it look bad for Andrew, but there was no "theater movies only" rule mentioned from his POV. Was there miscommunication? Obviously, yes. Is Andrew going back on something he meant earlier? I don't think so.
This is the best analysis I could do of the discussion, but let me know if you guys agree or disagree. **And please be nice**. I know some people have been a bit unsavory about this, but those comments are unhelpful for this discussion.
TLDR: He watched them on VOD after they were in theaters during the summer league, which he shortened to saying that he didn't watch them in theaters so he wouldn't have won that bonus star. Be nice in the comments.