I've been replaying the Sims 2, here are my thoughts as compared to the Sims 4
I want to begin this comparison by saying a few things:
1. Sims 2 is the first sims game I remember playing, I began it at probably seven or eight years old, and I've long held it as my favourite game in the series
2. I'm accessing the Sims 2 from back in around 2014 when Origin gave away the complete game for free, I'm aware that is no longer an option for players
3. Some of what I dislike about the Sims 2 is absolutely due to technology limitations of the time. I'm going to try in this review to indicate when I think this is, but I may easily miss some things
4. This is only going to be a review of gameplay features, I'm not getting into cost of any of the packs, nor am I discussing what the game is like "at launch" because I began playing the Sims 2 as a literal child with the "Double Deluxe" edition, so I don't know what TS2 is like at launch, nor do I remember much of TS4 at launch besides the fact it didn't even have family trees.
5. This is ONLY a review of TS2 compared to TS4, I no longer have access to TS3. I did play it extensively, but I no longer have access to my copies because I was an idiot child who never uploaded them to Origin despite owning every single game.
With that out of the way, let's get into my subjective opinions about the Sims:
**Animations**
In most ways, I prefer the animations in the Sims 2. I like the detail in how clogged toilets are repaired using a plunger and how when Sims talk on the phone, they pace around their living room. The Sims 2 is full of charming, little details like this, which I think is a huge plus in its playability. Sims, if forced to do an action too many times in a row (or an action they dislike, for example cleaning), will look at the camera and point to themselves like, "Me? *Really?"* and although I think some players may find this immersion breaking, I personally find it charming.
That said--in the Sims 4, if you're cleaning up dishes which still have food on them, Sims scrape them into the trash before putting them in the dishwasher. I've watched my Sims 2 sims put a whole bowl of spoiled macaroni directly into their dishwasher, which I found suprising because of how otherwise detailed the game is.
**Mechanics**
I didn't think I'd miss TS4's emotion system, but I do. It affects my game play more than I realized, because if I have sims who are a couple, and they get flirty, it affects the interactions I end up choosing. If they stay happy/fine, then I have my sims stick to more friendly actions with each other. It doesn't really affect the game the way we were told it would back in 2014, but I do ultimately enjoy having it.
The fact TS2 has really solidly built up genetics is really cool, though, and it's fun to see generational traits, and it's fun changing your sim's hair colour doesn't affect how their baby may be born. I also enjoy the chemistry system, and the fact there's a mix of silly and serious turn-ons/offs. I wish TS4, in it's much more recent chemistry system, included hair colour and other physical traits. I understand why they didn't, because if I had to guess, the devs didn't want to be offensive with, "Turn off - fat", which is probably for the best, but I do think including different occults & hair colours would be an improvement to TS4's symptoms. Maybe my sim is a monster fucker, Sims Team.
That said, I appreciate TS4 being more broadly inclusive, although it definitely took awhile to implement some of the changes (for example, polyamory) and some are still imperfect (pronouns). A lot of this is due to different conversations and attitudes on a scale larger than the Sims team, but I do appreciate having more say over a sim's gender, romantic attraction, and woo-hoo interests, as well as a greater variety of skin tones (again--this is something which took FAR too long to implement, and is still imperfect) and body types (again, imperfect, there is a lot of criticism about the shape of fat sims in TS4, I do believe TS2's "fat" sims are a product of gaming limitations, given that "fit" sims also look basically just like the standard sim body type, and obviously a lower level of affecting how sims are shaped is due to when TS2 released, but I do think it is ultimately a positive in TS4's favour).
I also think TS4 has a better skill system. I do think TS4 probably has... too many skills... at this point, but I like how a sim who is a level 10 in violin, is also not an expert in every other instrument, writing, painting, and all other creative skills. Again, I'm sure this is just a limitation of the time, but I prefer the variety in TS4. I do miss TS2's cleaning skill, though.
Finally, I prefer the Sims 2 memory system. The new milestone system is cool, although very late, but it's fun to earn memories which may not be a milestone. Being able to look back and see when you met the sim you eventually married is cool.
**Interactions Between Sims**
I think, generally, TS4 is wide, but shallow in many aspects, but I will say, I prefer how it arranges social interactions. In TS2, some actions are flirty, even if you may not guess they would be. For example, for many of the interactions under "Ask" are asked in a flirty way, with the asker leaning in to the other sim, and in some cases this makes sense "What turns you on?" is a flirty question. But, "What are your skills?" being perceived a certain way is a bit irritating.
For years, I've really valued how many kiss and flirt interactions there are in TS2, and I still absolutely do (the options for how sims can play together are also phenomenal), but I feel like the friendly conversation topics are limited. When my Sim became unexpectedly pregnant and told her boyfriend, I really missed TS4's "deep conversation" and "share big news" options. Having them chat like it was any other conversation didn't feel at all the same. It really just comes down to how you role play an interaction, but to me it just feels better to click an interaction labeled something which fits the situation rather than "Chat."
You also can't ask a sim to be your boyfriend/girlfriend if you aren't a teenager ("going steady"), and it feels strange to jump straight to engagement without ever having the discussion to become exclusive.
That said---I love how in TS2, two sims can feel differently about each other. I had two sims go on a date, and they fell in love at different times, one while they slow danced, and the other at the conclusion of the date. It makes the story of it more engaging, and it makes repairing relationships much more complicated. (Mary-Sue pleasant, please stop poking me, I know I smooth talked your husband, but we're literally friends and you agreed to come over to my house! ...i ended up woo-hooing mary-sue pleasant, she's in love with me now)
**Wants & Fears / Aspirations**
I prefer TS2's wants and fears system. I find it guides my play to a greater degree than TS4's, but I do feel, depending on your Sim's aspiration, a lot of those TS2 wants can be a bit... "same-y". Sometimes, they put you on a longer-term quest (Shout out to my girl who is on a quest to woo-hoo with 10 different sims, currently), but other times, I just find my sim's rolling "Buy this object." a thousand times over. But, I seldomly pay much attention at all to TS4's whims.
I think prefer TS4's aspirations, though. I don't like how simple some are, and I do like how TS2's are something which guides an entire sim's entire life, but again, it's sort of exhausting if you have a Fortune sim and all they want to do is buy things. I personally would like a system where you have a broad aspiration a-la TS2, which guide your general interests and wants, but also aspiration's more like TS4's, and maybe whatever aspiration you chose would make certain TS4 goals harder or more difficult to achieve. If this was designed to work with burnout and the emotion system, you could have a romance-oriented sim doing a family-focused aspiration, and they are more likely to burnout/be in a tense mood because these actions are less congruent with their larger goals. Still, I love that TS2 adds a randomly-assigned "Lifetime Goal", I think it's an enjoyable level of complexity. I also like TS2's dual aspiration system and the Aspiration Benefits.
*Edit: I also like how romance sims in TS4 aren't exclusively looking to date/kiss/woohoo as many people as possible. I like the in TS4, you can have a romantic aspiration, but want to be with only one person and have the most fulfilling romantic life you can with them.*
I don't... think I really like either game's aspiration reward store very much. In TS2, I use the money tree, romance tub, and elixir of live, but not really much of the others. In TS4, I use some of the traits, and the potion which resets the life stage, but besides that, I leave it be. I don't know what I'd like instead.
**Daily Activities**
TS2 has more simple chores than TS4. Fridges run out of food, so you need to order groceries (this sort of comes back in TS4 if you use "Simple Living", but I feel like there's a difference between having to source specific ingredients and hoping the store has what you want, or needing to be an entire farmer, and just going to a grocery store and leaving with a basket of groceries). In TS2, you also need to go to the store to purchase new clothes and jewelry, which I really enjoy. It's a bit annoying and expensive, but I think it's a level of realism I enjoy. Again, there is clothing shopping in TS4, through multiple ways, and if you have High School Years, you can access certain outfits *only* through thrifting, but it's optional. I have a lot of fun sending my brides to Amelia's Closet to buy their wedding gowns.
However, I think in regards to books, TS4 has the leg up, because all books in TS2 can be any skill book. If you read to gain a cleaning skill, put the book down, you can then pick up the exact same book and study lifelong happiness from it. I like how in TS4, you need to buy individual skill books, and you can't just read a single book and max your skills. I enjoy how sims become bored or tense depending on if the skill level is too simple or too advanced for them.
**Work and Careers**
I don't know if everyone appreciates this, but I enjoy how TS2 offers only a small percentage of careers each day, whereas TS4 gives you all options. When I was a child, this was something I didn't appreciate, and I remember adoring the first time I realized I could just get any job I wanted, but having gone back to TS2, I had a lot of fun balancing the fact my sim needs money, but they have a dream career, and having them work in a job they dislike while trying to get their dream. It's frustrating, but it makes simply getting the job far more rewarding.
That said: I think I prefer how promotions work in TS4 more. For one thing, if your sim is promoted in TS2, and their new hours end after you came home from work, you have to work two shifts. For example, if at level 3, your workday on Wednesday ended at 3pm, you get promoted, and your Wednesday hours begin at 5pm for your level 4 job, then you have to turn around and go straight back to work. There may be some players who enjoy this, and on one occasion my sim ended up being promoted twice in a row due to this, so it was pretty fun, but it can also be frustrating. I also generally prefer how TS4 doesn't require making friends. It's a cool mechanic in theory, but I just personally dislike it.
Career *rewards* in TS2 can be cooler, though. In TS4 it's like, "oh, cool, a desk." but in TS2 it's like, "oh, cool, a phone i can use to call the grim reaper." Not really equivalent, although some TS2 career rewards are way less cool than others.
**Vacations**
God, I miss TS2's vacations. They're definitely... flawed, and I like how in TS4, for most of the vacation worlds (unfortunately not all), you could live there or visit as a vacation, so you can choose how you want your vacation to look, but I miss TS2's vacation mementos. I miss staying in Hotels. I miss my sims feeling like a tourist. This isn't meant to be a post including TS3, but I think (the widely beloved World Adventures pack) set up a precedent for a vacation system I personally do not enjoy, where the focus is less on feeling like, well, a vacation, if that makes sense. I would like a system where you can do the cool adventuring stuff people liked in World Adventures (although, as an IRL archaeologist, please stop tomb raiding T\_T), and where the world isn't just a stereotypical tourist town and you can be from there, but Sims who visit can just... order room service and learn a sea shanty from a pirate ghost. I don't go on many vacations in TS4.
**Build/Buy**
I hate building in TS2. I remember enjoying it as a child, but I find it really frustrating after getting used to TS4's. I like how you can choose bed frame and blanket options independently of each other SO much, I think some of the objects look nicer and feel more "real", but TS4 makes me excited to build. TS2 does not.
Playground equipment in TS2 is better, though, and I wish TS4 brought back modular swings. Also, cars exist in TS2.
I have a lot more to say about my feelings between the two, but this is an exceptionally long post already, so I'm going to end it here. I'll leave by repeating that in many ways, TS4 is wide but shallow, and although I established I'm not getting into the costs of packs, I do think it's telling how in order to match TS2 in certain areas, we had to wait until very recently (even a few months ago, in some instances) to match what TS2 had at launch/received much earlier in regard to the lifespan of the game. Still, I do really like the Sims 4! There is a lot of frustration with it, and the Sims team, much of which is valid, some of which I find to be exaggerated, but there are many moments while I play Sims 2 where I miss some element of TS4. I was afraid when I went back to play TS2, I'd come away thinking, "Man, Sims 4 is really bad," but that hasn't really been my experience. It's clear in this post it is less impressive than Sims 2 in many aspects, but I don't think I'd be making this post if I felt TS2 was better in literally every single way.
Anyway, I wanted to discuss the difference in hobbies, but this post is ages long, so if anybody would like to hear my thoughts on it, or any other comparative element, let me know. I'm going to send my teen sim to University soon, so let me know if you'd like a different post comparing and contrasting only University, or any other pack! Dag dag!