RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thesopranos • … • u/Freefall_J

Would phil have been a less-Petty, reasonable boss had had billy not been killed?

I got the sense Phil's driving force is his hatred of Tony Soprano. And that's entirely related to not only his cousin Tony B. killing his brother Billy but Tony also taking away the satisfaction of revenge from him. He hated Tony and his crew so much, he actually believed the ceremony for made men in NJ did *not* even involve pricking your finger, totally going against tradition.

I felt it was Phil's open and constant disrespect of the Soprano family that influenced and emboldened the New York crew to look down further to the NJ crew. Fat Dom had the balls to walk into Soprano territory alone and mouth off about a dead Capo (that he killed) thinking he was untouchable. Coco had a big head and thought he might as well lay a finger on a NJ boss' daughter and sexually harass her.

So my question is: had Billy not been killed, do you think Phil might have been a decent boss? One who could compromise or be reasoned with. Not give in to his hatred and believe anything he hears as long as it makes NJ look bad? And certainly one who doesn't passively promote disrespecting Tony Soprano and his people.

— 0