Tony lost respect from his guys because he failed to respect his guys. Change my mind.
Bobby was out earning for Tony, almost lost an eye then made Tony whole on loyalty. Married to Tony's sister, even. Tony considers his 'so called' loyalty a ploy. "It was a maneuver, Carlo, cause he knew it was his own f\*cking fault." How cynical you gotta be, eh? Add to why Carlo flipped.