RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/thesopranos • … • u/BKtoDuval

Almost done with a total rewatch. It makes no sense for Tony not to die at the end.

I'm rewatching this after 20 years. I'm watching it over three weeks instead of a few years, so shorter processing times between episodes makes me realize, damn, this show is really dark. Maybe I've just gotten older and crankier but I didn't remember it being so dark and even tragic back then. I have two episodes left and I can't wait to be done. It's really sociopathic.

Season 6 especially is so dark that I think would be unfitting artistically that he walks off and lives happily ever after. I don't get any debate on it. There's no one likable by the time Season 6 is wrapping up. I do feel for AJ. But artistically the only fitting conclusion would be for Tony to be shot and to add to the stylistic tragedy, for it to happen in front of his family.

It's even better that we don't see it. I can't believe 20 years ago I thought, "hmm, did he die? What happened?" Today it's clear it's the most appropriate ending.

Edit: I think another indication was the only person who still felt they had value in his life was Dr. Melfi and she seemed to be finally convinced that she couldn't help him. Made no sense to continue living.

— 0