My new in depth senate prediction.
Since there seems to be a little bit of confusion with my margins I just want to clear something up: Louisiana and Mississippi are just bellow 15 points. I split the likely category because R+14 and R+6 are absolutely not the same thing. Kansas 2020 (R+14.5) and Colorado 2012 (D+5.3) should not both be in that likely category.
Now, moving on to the actual politics part.
The generic ballot will probably be roughly D+8, or 10 points better than 2024, that’s why so many non swing red states like South Carolina and Kansas being in the single digits. While environment matters, candidate quality is the biggest factor in most competitive senate races.
Collins probably loses by about 2 in the 2nd round of voting. She clearly is a weaker candidate now and seems far more apathetic to the whole politics thing. She probably wants to retire but is being convinced by the party establishment to stay in and keep Maine competitive.
Cooper is definitely going to flip North Carolina, the only real question is by how much. He’ll probably win by 5-6 points because he’s a great candidate going against a mediocre candidate and environment. Cooper is also a more national candidate which will help him a lot with fundraising.
The same things about North Carolina are true about Georgia. Ossoff is already being talking about as a presidential candidate. He’s definitely a national democrat, while his republican challenger is far less known. This is why Ossoff will also probably win by about 6 points too (52-46) so a runoff won’t be necessary
Alaska is a weird state, it’s slowly getting bluer, has a lot of ticket splitting, and uses ranked choice voting. It’s like the anti New England: deep red federally, but can elect democrats in statewide races. These things help all Peltola, she’s going up against an unpopular incumbent in a blue wave year. She’ll most likely win by about 2 points in the 3rd round of voting.
For Iowa the only way democrats win the senate is if Sand wins by about 6 in the governors race, and Sand probably has a ceiling of 3. Iowa is going to be close as it’s a state that’s more likely to be affected by a wave year. However, democrats just don’t have the benchmark to get over the top.
For Nebraska, this race doesn’t feel that nationalized. There’s been very little polling done, and neither candidate is doing media circles. This probably helps Osborn do better than he did in 2024, but he’ll still probably lose by about 2 points.
Ohio and Texas are the states that are most likely to change rating. As of right now:
Husted definitely has some skeletons and brown is the far better candidate, but right now it still probably goes red by under a point due to the states partisan lean.
Of course, Texas was always going to be a nationalized senate race, and Talarico is definitely embracing that. It’ll probably help him in terms of funding, but harm him in terms of partisanship. Right now the Republican nominee is Cornyn, as he’s the states senator. Although, the Republican nominee Talarico as much as people say, he’s in an uphill battle either way, his odds of winning are 40% against Cornyn and 45% against Paxton. As Cornyn is still an unpopular senate and Paxton is a scandal ridden mess. The race might become tilt D as election night draws closer, but right now the states partisan lean lead’s Talarico to just barely losing.
Finally, Montana might be going down to single digits, but right now it’s R+12.
Margins:
15+
15-10
10-5
5-1
<1