I found an article about Season 3
I know in the comics there was some kind of predator but Axel...man I liked him as a goofy guy. I think Beth being a victim would be a waste...but what are your thoughts overall on this alternative character development? It might have been interesting if the victim had been a random survivor...but idk
I don't think Rick would have been able to trust anyone again, and there would have been a rift with Herschel.
https://www.cinemablend.com/television/2496409/the-walking-deads-original-plan-for-beth-was-even-more-gruesome