Oh Mandy, the problem with your character
So rewatching season 1 for the 11 millionth time, I think I realized what the problem with Mandy is.
She was written for the earlier pitch of the show but did not fit what the show became.
Hardcore fans of the West Wing know the original idea of the show was it was suppose to be about the West Wing staff, and the president might have 2 or 3 short appearances in an entire season. Sheen killed his first scene in the first episode and the show changed.
Bartlett's first scene made it very clear that the show was about "The president isn't a puppet or shadow figure, he's a good moral man trying to do his best for good of the country" And the show was about HIS STAFF. Not just "A political staff"
What's the difference. The show makes itself clear the staff aren't just smart capable political advisors, they are inherently "good" people, or at least they are trying to do good.
Something that happens in season 1 for every main character is they have at least 1 scene where they selflessly stand up for a "little guy" and/or a fellow staffer in trouble. Josh doesn't want the NSA card because he won't abandon his friends, Toby arranges a funeral for a homeless vet, CJ wants care for Pluie, also everyone rushes defense of Sam and his relationship with Laurie and Leo when his addiction is made public.
The Bartlett administration is one about caring for other people.
Except for Mandy. Mandy does not have a single scene or moment where she selflessly does anything for the good of other person.... heh... I mean unless you count the time she argues for the rights of a militia that is hold kids hostages and gets a Federal Agent killed.
Mandy is a true political consultant, her loyalty is to the person paying her until someone else pays her more, in a show that is about a "political staff" (with all the cut throat and back stabbing that happens in real world politics) Mandy would fit in, but in a show with an optimistic view of politics where the staff are filled good people... Mandy does not fit.
Sorry for the rant, I had to get it off my chest.