RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/theydidthemath • … • u/Don_Q_Jote

[SELF] Melt Nickels rather than Pennies for scrap value? It's a better option but you'll lose money either way.

A recent post questioned the prospect of melting US pennies for scrap value. Not good idea. Since 1982 pennies are no longer made from copper. Pennies are zinc (much cheaper) with a thin flash of copper. Many comments pointed this out. What many people may not know is that **US Nickels are made of 25% nickel and 75% copper** alloy. This got me wondering if melting down US nickels had any promise. It is a *better* option, but still a losing proposition.

Scrap prices from: https://iscrapapp.com/prices/*calculation does not account for the process of separating the two metals and making ingots of each, which would make the returns even worse.*

mass of **US Nickel = 5 gm, @ 75% Cu and 25% Ni**

75% Cu = 3.75 gm Cu \* ($2.18/lb, scrap Cu)\*(2.2 lb/1000 gm)= $0.00180 = 1.80 cents of Cu in each nickel

25% Ni = 1.25 gm Ni \* ($1.86/lb scrap Ni)\*(2.2 lb/1000 gm) = $0.0051 = 0.51 cents of Ni in each nickel.

1.81 + 0.51 = 2.32 cents per nickel --> 2.32/5 = 46.4% recovery --> **53.6% loss on every nickel**

mass of **US Penny = 2.5 gm, @ 2.5% Cu and 97.5 % Zn**

2.5% Cu = 0.062 gm Cu \* ($2.18/lb, scrap Cu)\*(2.2 lb/1000 gm)= $0.00030 =0.030 cents of Cu in each penny

97.5% Zn = 2.438 gm Zn \* ($0.21/lb scrap Zn)\*(2.2 lb/1000 gm)= $.00113 =0.113 cents of Zn in each penny.

0.030 + 0.113 = 0.143 cents per penny--> 0.143/1 = 14.3% recovery --> **85.7% loss on every penny**

— 0