Just Bought a Thinkpad T480 and Having Battery Issues

At first everything appeared to be fine with the used machine. Was getting about three or four hours of battery use when I first tested the laptop. It's only been three days since arriving but now Battery 2 is stuck at 0% and only says charging when plugged in. Battery 1 does charge to 100% but quickly drains, about 1% per minute.

Lenovo Vantage shows both have a cycle count over 430 but do not appear to have any health issues.

Am I missing something that is causing the battery issues or is it time for two new batteries?

UPDATE: Well I’m confused. I’m using my wife’s 61W MacBook Pro adapter for the last 30 minutes and now Battery 2 is at 94% and Battery 1 is at 33% and charging.

I had been using my work laptop which is a Dell 65W adapter since its connected to a docking station and I’m waiting on my Lenovo adapter to arrive