[TOMT][Short story] Horror story involving a horse and a body of water
This is a short story I read in high school, circa 2000-2004, though the story may well be older than that. It was in a random horror anthology I picked up -- for the longest time I assumed it was [Urban Horrors](https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1912190.Urban_Horrors), but I've looked over the list of stories in that and nothing seems to match. I believe it was the very first story in the book.
I'm pretty sure the protagonist was a woman, though I could be wrong. The story involved them standing alone near water late at night. I'm not sure if it was a naturally occurring body of water or a swimming pool. The latter is what I picture when I think of it, but I also seem to vaguely remember a pier being mentioned. Rising from the water was a skeletal or decaying horse. I'm inclined to think the horse was a symbol and the true horror came from what was going on in the character's life, with lots of little flashback-type scenes interspersed throughout, but now I'm really stretching.
I remember finding it kind of slow and pointless at the time, but for some reason it's been haunting me ever since.