RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tipofmytongue • … • u/Laremere

[TOMT][Quote] When an author was asked to write something exploring mysterious mountains in their world, they reply was close to "then I would need further mountains"

I have a vague memory of an anecdote I heard:

When Jrr Tolkien was asked to write a book that explored some distant mountains in his world, he rejected the idea, saying "Then I would need further mountains." The point of his response was that the distant and mysterious mountains served a purpose of making the world feel larger, and containing further mysteries and adventures unknown. If they were to remove that mystery by exploring those mountains, they would then need to create "further mountains" so that the world would continue to feel large and full of the unknown.

This anecdote comes to mind when thinking about how some franchises (eg, Starwars) have the tendency to resolve many small mysteries which were used for world building in the original works. They do this because those are the questions they know will draw in fans. However it only makes the original work feel smaller, and full of coincidences.

Unfortunately for me, this memory seems to have major faults as I can't find anything related to this online. Maybe it wasn't Jrr Tolkien, maybe it wasn't mountains, maybe I'm missing something else?

— 0