How many tires to replace after puncture with low milage AWD Hybrid Honda?
EDIT: RIP title typo
Hey all, I have a 2025 Honda CR-V with about 11k miles on it. I got a sidewall puncture the other day and I'm going to get the tire swapped. The car is AWD and a hybrid. My question is, how many do I replace?
My plan is to replace the pictured one and the one opposite it on the same axle. With my cars tire rotation pattern, they will always stay across from each other.
My owners manual says to replace the tire with one with the same size, speed rating, load range, and cold tire pressure. It also says it's best to replace all 4 at once, but is ok to replace just 2 at once, given they are on the same axle.
Give my situation, I need tires in about a day, so not really time to fuss around finding a perfect match used tire with the same wear to swap in.
My plan is to replace the punctured tire and the one opposite of it with some Pirelli scorpion A/S that have the same size, load range, speed rating, and pressure rating as my current OEM Bridgestone Ecopias. So I will have matching tires side to side, but mismatched front to rear. Plan on these pirellis since they are the cheapest tire from a decent company that I can find in the right size and leadtime.
Tire shop says they recommend replacing all 4 due to wear on drivetrain components with AWD system, but I dont see what excessive wear would come from since my existing tires only have 11k miles (7-8/32 remaining) on them and it's not like the CRV has a locked center diff or anything? And the Honda owners manual seems to imply that replacing just 2 is acceptable?
What would you do? Any maybe different question... What would you recommend?