Teaching generosity versus being taken advantage of
My three year old is the sweetest little muffin you’d hope to have. He loves to share, he loves to get things for people, he gets so excited when he can offer you a taste of something. (Side note - we do not in any way push sharing of their own things, the only things we remind them to take turns on are communally owned things)
I love that and it makes me feel great to see him so willing.
But he is starting to give away everything he has and then get upset when he realizes it.
Like if he has a scoop of custard from Culver’s, he loves to offer a taste. His big brother always takes him up on it; even if they have the same thing. It’s sometimes sweet but lately my 7yo has been trying new things to get more of whatever his brother has
Now I’m not saying I want to tell him to be less generous to giving but he’s so overly willing to just give and give and give and say nothing - and it really makes me sad when he realizes he fed most of his treat to his brothers stuffed tigers and he has none.
My seven year old ABSOLUTELY exploits it. I know that’s normal but I shouldn’t have to worry so much that he’s going to trick his brother out of 99% of whatever treat or toy he has.
They both are very attached to their stuffed animals, we basically live in a zoo of sentient animals.
My oldest will ask for bites for all of his tigers and obviously eat it all himself.
I guess what I’m wondering is how do I - or even SHOULD I - navigate so he doesn’t lose out on his own things, or help him understand he’s being manipulated?
We remind him all the time, “Pizza, you are allowed to say no to Potato, you can say no I don’t want to share. That is your special dessert.”
I want my boys to have a generous heart but never feel like they have end up with nothing because they want to be kind.
Any thoughts?
\*\*\*\*\*\*\* ETA
Before I get dog piled by 75 people saying the same thing - we have been working on this with 7yo. This is a new thing, not something that’s just been going on for months.
If he tries to trick him out of his stuff, he doesn’t get the same treats again, he’s lost privileges, he’s been given tasks to do for his brother.
But he’s also pending a diagnosis for ADHD/ODD/PDA.
I \*still\* want to know the best way to instill \*from the beginning\* that it’s fine to be kind but you shouldn’t at your own expense.