Are there any books that provide a history of all of Tolkien’s writings? I want to know when stories in the Legendarium were written relative to each other.
Tolkien didn’t develop his world linearly. Eärendil was the first character Tolkien wrote but was never published in any work during Tolkien’s lifetime. The story of Beren and Luthein, in some form, predates the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings trilogy. However, none of these characters appear in Tolkien’s work except as a brief references.
We know that Tolkien went through many iterations of the stories that would appear in the Silmarillion. Many versions weren’t stabilized when Christopher Tolkien compiled the Silmarillion.
When a character in LoTR references a story from the Silmarillion, do we have any idea what JRR Tolkien’s contemporary version of the story was? For example, when Elrond compares Frodo to the “elf-friends of old, Hador, and Hurin, and Turin, and Beren […]”, do know at what stage each of those stories were in? Were they essential the version from the Silmarillion that were familiar with, or were these just names Tolkien threw out. Similarly, in The Hobbit when Gandalf considers his death when he and the company are stuck in the tree, had Tolkien decided that Gandalf was an immortal Maiar? Did the concept of Maiar exist at this point in Tolkien’s writing?
Ideally, I would love a reference that whenever a character from the Legendarium, is referenced in LoTR, I can see what the contemporary version of their story would be. I’m guessing this doesn’t exist, so just a timeline of when the stories were written would be great.