RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tolkienfans • … • u/chromeflex

If you were offered a wish that one of Tolkiens unfinished works would be completed, what would you chose

There are a lot of candidates

Obviously there are the OG Silmarillion and the Children of Hurin, which exist as a seamless narrative, but both are thanks to Christopher’s editorial contribution.

Then there’s Lay of Leithian that’s just one 1/4 short of the Tale’s finale.

Or Tuor and the fall of Gondolin, that only covers roughly 1/4 of the intended story

Or Wanderings of Hurin, in which Hurin never got to Nargothrond, nevermind bringing the gold to Doriath

Or other works like Aldarion and Erendis, Tar-Elmar and The New Shadow, and some more.

Personally, as much as I’m intrigued about the revised battle for Gondolin or the poetic hunt of Carcaroth, the conclusion of Hurin’s story catches my interest the most, it’s so different from the previous drafts so you can’t stop guessing what could be the endgame for Asgon and the other outlaws from Hurin’s company, who are now much more “good” and noble compared to the Quenta version. Would Asgon die fighting for the gold in Thingol’s halls? Would he leave Hurin and lead survivors to the mouth of Sirion? Or would he tragically die either in Nargothrond, or on the way to Doriath, which will lead to the corruption of Hurin’s man. That we’ll never know

— 0