RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tolkienfans • … • u/No_Variation_2199

A random thought while reading UT

I am reading the incomplete version of Children of Hurin in Unfinished Tales, and Thingol’s benevolence and generosity with Turin somewhat surprised me. I mean, I understood in while I was reading the Simarillion that Thingol genuinely cared for Turin… as in the same way I think the friendship of Beleg of Turin developed, over the course of their years together. But I didn’t realize until this point Thingol took Turin to be his foster child the first time he sees him… which is quite amazing actually, considering how he treated Beren and how he tried to lock Lúthien up to keep her from seeing him. I didn’t think Thingol liked men at all (or any outsiders) and Turin and Beren are also related (Turin’s mother Morwen is related to Beren), so they must look somewhat alike. It must be pretty amazing for him to do that, and that was something none of the elven kings did before or after.

I was wondering if this was the way for Thingol to show regret over what happened in Beren + Luthien’s case. I mean, he basically tried to remedy everything wrong with his relationship with Luthien in Turin’s case: when Turin decides to leave (because he thinks he is going to be unwelcomed after accidentally causing the death of one of Thingol’s counselors) Thingol didn’t do anything about it, and later almost supported every attempt wholeheartedly by Beleg to try to bring back Turin to say they weren’t mad at him. I was thinking Thingol perhaps thought that he wouldn’t lose his daughter had he not sent Beren on an impossible task and had granted them more freedom (following Melina’s advice), and that’s why he showed so much restraint and love by freedom in this case. Not to say the outcome is any better, though… Does anyone have an opinion on this?

— 0