Lovecraft-y stuff in LoTR
I love Tolkien to bits. And I love Lovecraft to bits. I almost never enjoy re-reading something I've consumed before, but I re-read Tolkien & Lovecraft endlessly & I doubt that'll ever stop. They both just... make me *feel* things.
But, obviously, they make me feel *different* things - at least 99% of the time. And *LoTR* in particular is Tolkien at his most un-Lovecraft-y - at least for 99% of it, including all of the main story:
* It's plot-heavy: It wants to sit the reader down & tell them a sprawling, complex story, *not* just to provide linear buildup that's laser-focussed on helping the reader have a singular emotional experience * It's character-heavy: Its protagonists are richly drawn & the reader is meant to enjoy them & care about them as interesting story-elements in their own right; they're *not* just a quickly sketched everyman cipher, made as universal as possible to help the reader's immersion in the story-elements that actually matter * Its setting is binary & intelligible: Middle-Earth is a sacred prize, contested by two clearly defined & morally categorizable sets of opposing cosmic powers - 180 degrees from a universe that's just the transiently realised fever-dream of a mad god * Its setting is human-centric: Sauron wants to conquer all the humans & make them forced labourers in factories; the Valar want to preserve human autonomy by meddling as little as possible, while encouraging/helping humans to resist Sauron - 180 degrees from a setting where humans are a footnote, created unintentionally by one set of uncaring aliens & destined to be crushed underfoot by another set of uncaring aliens * Its characters drive the resolution of the plot; the protagonists (especially the humblest & most relatable ones) are empowered to make moral choices that determine the outcome of the story. That's probably where *LoTR* differs most fundamentally from cosmic horror, where human powerlessness is *literally the point* & the best we can do is enjoy our silly little lives today (because there's no guarantee we'll get a tomorrow) & give in completely to imagination (because reality sucks donkey balls, & isn't actually any more solid or consistent or dependable than the dream-worlds that we can explore while asleep or with the help of artists) * It has lots of action-writing and multiple eucatastrophes
*But...*
There are still some places in *LoTR* where I get that Lovecraft Tingle, just as strongly as when I read *Mountains of Madness* or *Strange High House in the Mist* or *Nameless City* or *Sarnath* or *Haunter of the Dark*. Never in *The Hobbit* (where the tone is different) & never in *The Silmarillion* (where we're given a top-down, god's-eye view) but multiple times in *LoTR* \- not thematically of course, but definitely at the level of imagery, atmosphere & immersiveness:
* **The Old Forest**: The Hobbits are alone, with no wizard to explain the history of the land they've wandered into & no warrior to protect them. They know intuitively that they're somewhere profoundly unsafe, but they've no clear understanding of the threat & certainly no idea how to combat it. There's no unambiguous evil that they're righteously resisting; they've merely strayed into the territory of something alien, uncommunicative & implacably, impersonally vengeful, which existed long, long before hobbits & almost seems to *be* the landscape rather than just inhabiting it. There's no visible antagonist they can fight against or even run away from; instead they're being suffocated by the very air around them, ensnared in an impossible geometry where all paths lead only deeper inward & struggling to stay awake or make rational decisions while they steadily lose control of their own faculties. * **The Barrow-Downs**: Once again the hobbits are alone, with no guide or guard. And, once again, the prose is minutely descriptive - the focus isn't on dialogue or events; it's on the hobbits' moment-to-moment feelings & sense-impressions - the wild swings in temperature, the clammy sensation of cold sweat in the mist, the echoing sound of each other's fading voices when they get lost, their steadily mounting dread as the sun goes down & finally the stark, ominous, bare standing stones. * **The Watcher in the Water**: Tolkien wasn't a prolific writer of tentacle-monsters, but the one time he did try his hand at that trope, he nailed it. It evokes the fear of drowning & the fear of lurking threats hidden beneath the surface of bodies of water; it uses the visual strangeness of marine invertebrates. And, like all the best tentacle-monsters, it's vast & inhuman & uncommunicative - but not merely a mindless animal, like some supersized version of a real-world giant squid simply looking for a meal; there's *just a hint* of deliberate malice when it makes a beeline right for the ring-bearer. * **The Nameless Things**: What could be more structurally Lovecraftian than a 2nd-hand account of incomprehensible monstrosities, related by a narrator who withholds the full truth (because even knowledge of the Things is inherently dangerous), but gives up *just enough* information to fire the imagination? A narrator who didn't defeat or destroy the monstrosities but merely managed to escape them & find his way back to the land of the living, and who was fundamentally changed by the experience? Neither Frodo nor the reader ever gets a proper explanation of their origin, history or motivations but we do know that they were always there - long, long before the world took its current shape. Unlike Sauron & Saruman & the ringwraiths - or even the barrow-wights - they're never defeated or destroyed; when the story ends, they're still there, steadily gnawing away at the roots of the world... * **The Stone of Erech**: For me, this single piece of imagery really helps to sell the whole Paths of the Dead sub-plot - this inscrutable, massive rock in a lonely spot high up in the mountains, which *might* just be a location where long-dead people performed their solumn rituals but *might* actually have the power to trap souls in a living purgatory... I'm just a huge sucker for silent, uncarved megaliths sitting there mysteriously in uninhabited patches of green; that definitely helps my appreciation of both this & the barrow-downs. That's probably because I live in northwestern Europe, so [enormous standing stones older than the pyramids, that jut out of the ground like teeth](https://www.highlandexperience.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/4610/2021/01/orkney-standing-stones-P18-scaled.jpg?w=1000&h=1000&zoom=2) were a semi-regular sight on childhood holidays; it's *very* tempting to think of them as somehow magical & I always love stories in which they *literally are* magical - instruments of necromancy rather than markers of burial. Tolkien grew up (mostly) in England, so I have to assume he saw the same things in the countryside & felt the same way. *Nameless City* uses different imagery (abandoned ancient cities in the middle east rather than henges in Europe) but artistically it does essentially the same thing; it exploits that otherworldly *feeling* that ancient sites can give us, but literalizes it with a story where the site *actually is* otherworldly.