RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tolkienfans • … • u/roacsonofcarc

A little-noticed instance of direct intervention by the Valar: Cirion's gift of Calenardhon to the Rohirrim.

One of the things I keep saying on this sub is that Giuseppe Pezzini's essay, “The Lords of the West: Cloaking, Freedom and the Divine Narrative in Tolkien's Poetics,” has a claim to be the best piece about Tolkien to come out in recent years. You should read it. Here it is:

[https://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/10023/18378/Pezzini\_2019\_JIS\_LordsoftheWest\_AAM.pdf;jsessionid=D506951D8CFE81138A43C2C0569E409A?sequence=1](https://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/10023/18378/Pezzini_2019_JIS_LordsoftheWest_AAM.pdf;jsessionid=D506951D8CFE81138A43C2C0569E409A?sequence=1)

Pezzini's thesis is that the Valar, far from being the idlers and do-nothings many readers consider them, are constantly shaping events in the late Third Age. One of the ways they do this is by putting visions directly in the minds of characters in the story. I have in the past compiled an posted a long list of examples; for the present, one will do. It is found in chapter 6.3, when Frodo and Sam have reached the point of utter exhaustion on the slopes of Mount Doom:

>Suddenly a sense of urgency which he did not understand came to Sam. It was almost as if he had been called: ‘Now, now, or it will be too late!’ He braced himself and got up. Frodo also seemed to have felt the call. He struggled to his knees.

The present post is about an instance of this kind of intervention which seems to have gone unnoticed; it is found in *Unfinished Tales*, in the essay “Cirion and Eorl,”written, as Christopher Tolkien believed, after the publication of *LotR.* The last portion of this describes the circumstances under which the Steward Cirion offered, and Eorl accepted, the gift of Calenardhon to be the home of Eorl's people. After the oaths were sworn, as Cirion and Eorl parted Cirion said this:

>The reward I offered in joy and fulness of heart at our deliverance now seems little. But I believe that the words of my oath, **which I had not forethought ere I spoke them, were not put in my mouth in vain.** We will part then in hope.

UT p. 307 (emphasis added). The next paragraph stresses the historicity of Cirion's acknowledgment that the gift of Calenardhon came into his mind from outside:

>After the manner of the Chronicles no doubt much of what is here put into the mouths of Cirion and Eorl at their parting was said and considered in the debate of the night before; but it is certain that Cirion said at parting his words concerning the inspiration of his oath, for he was a man of little pride and of great courage and generosity of heart, the noblest of the Stewards of Gondor.

(Added vocabulary note: I wondered if there was a precedent for Tolkien's use of "forethought" as the past tense of a verb, There is, it's Old English *foreðencean.*)

— 0