Dreaming, who's in charge?
The most famous dream in all of Middle earth.
*Seek for the Sword that was broken* *In Imladris it dwells* *There shall be counsels taken* *Stronger than Morgul-spells.* *There shall be shown a token* *That Doom is near at hand,* *For Isildur's Bane shall waken,* *And the Halfling forth shall stand*
This dream comes to Faramir many times, and Boromir once, and sets in motion Boromir coming to Rivendell to find the meaning. There he discovers about the ring, and about Aragorn, his broken sword and his claim to the throne. And about the Hobbits of course.
We take it that it was either the Valar, or Eru himself who sent this dream to the sons of Denethor, to get them involved, and therefore Gondor, next door neighbor to Mordor.
What I am proposing, I'm not saying this is true, as I have zero proof of it. All I have is a hint.
Gandalf learned from the Valar. He was their servant, and they were his mentors. From Nienna he learns pity. From Manwe and Mandos he learns wisdom. But from Lorien, he learns to put fair visions, desires and dreams into others. Gandalf seems to have practiced this when in Valinor, and the Elves wondered where these visions came from.
See where I'm going with this? What do you think of the possibility that Gandalf used his ability to send that dream to the brothers, to get at least one of them to Rivendell, to get Gondor's help in his plan to destroy the ring and getting Aragorn on the throne? I wonder, have I been staring this Easter Egg for 40+ years and only now it occurs to me?
As always, great thoughts welcomed.