RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tolkienfans • … • u/CapnJiggle

Tolkien’s revisions

Reading through NoME has, naturally, made me think about the revisions that Tolkien made to his legendarium after the publication of LOTR. I haven’t finished the book yet, but so far I haven’t found much that I would consider an improvement over his earlier writing.

The primary example is of course the “mythological” vs “scientific” versions of the Sun and Moon (which Hostetter himself refers to). The sun and moon being created from the last fruits of the Trees, raised into the skies and guided by demi-gods through the Doors of Night and Dawn, a sign both to the Children and to Melkor that the Valar have not forgotten them… or just two gaseous & rocky spheres obeying orbital mechanics that are taught in schoolrooms today?

I know which I would prefer to read about. Do you agree? Are there revisions that you consider improvements in Tolkien’s later work?

— 0