RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tolkienfans • … • u/DanPiscatoris

Isildur and the Ring

I saw someone mention this on another LOTR related subreddit the other day, but I couldn't find anything on it. The person claimed that after the defeat of Sauron, while Isildur was travelling north to Rivendell, his intention was to deliver the Ring to Elrond to try to destroy it based on the advice of his son Elendur. He claimed that the source was in the Unfinished Tales. I am not terribly familiar with UT, but I took a look in the Disaster of the Gladden Fields section. There are only two instances where Isildur and Elendur discuss the ring. Both after they are ambushed by Orcs. The first is Elendur asking whether Isildur could use the ring to repel the Orcs. Isildur claims his will is not strong enough and laments his decision to keep the ring. The second is where Elendur pushes Isildur to use the ring and escape. Is there any basis to this claim?

— 0