RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tollywood • … • u/thebluegod

Am I crazy for not understanding the hype around Kalki?

Saw the movie over the weekend, and thought it was very average. IMO Nag Ashwin should stick to strong scripts with high emotional connection (like his past films), rather than an effects-heavy sci-fi film.

Don't get me wrong, I really wanted this movie to be good. I think Nag Ashwin has made great movies. But Kalki is probably at the bottom of that list. Some issues I had:

* Too many non-native Telugu speakers trying to speak Telugu. From the first scene, this was extremely distracting. I think saying this is a Pan-Indian cinema is not a good excuse - we've made MANY Pan-Indian cinemas at this point that did not sacrifice the Telugu experience. At the very least, they should have taken care to have proper Telugu dubbing for key characters from our mythology (>!Krishna!<). * Over-reliance on "borrowed" imagery from western films & video games, rather than coming up with something that is unique to Indian culture. They did not take advantage of our mythology successfully. There's so much cool imagery and ideas they could have pulled from, instead of trying to recreate shots from Dune or Star Wars. Or using weapons designs from Halo, etc. The entire visual language of the film felt very random, without a unifying theme to tie it all together. * Lack of establishing shots of Kashi and Shambala. In general they could've done a lot more to make these places feel more real. Just look at the difference between locations in this movie vs. something like Mahishmati. * Comedic aspects did not land, and Prabhas does not have the charisma to pull off one-liners like Starlord or Tony Stark. This to me is just a casting thing, I just don't think Prabhas has enough range for this anymore. * Lack of emotional resonance in the screenplay. You don't get attached to any characters except Rajendra Prasad at the beginning. When an important character dies at the end, there is zero effect on the audience because it was not built up effectively. * Did not make use of Amitabh well. I don't think him being in a bunch of action scenes makes him a good character. I was expecting more poignant dialogs and dramatic moments from Ashwatthama. * Finally, the biggest issue is just the slow screenplay throughout. The first half almost entirely could have been cut. Even parts of the 2nd half dragged on until the last fight. Prabhas's character has basically zero connection to the main story until the ending. Honestly it was just not very engaging.

I think there are some plus points here, like Deepika's performance and the visual spectacle they were able to pull off. And it was a very novel idea from Nag Ashwin to mix sci-fi with Hindu mythology, but the execution was severely lacking. I don't understand people comparing this to Bahubali or RRR, it's no where even close to those. But it was a good try.

— 0