RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/toriamos • … • u/Repulsive_Chard_3652

That new fan checking in again: Night of the Hunters!!!

Howdy y'all! It's me again! If you haven't seen my previous posts, I came here a few days ago to ask for 3 diverse albums from different eras to check out as an introduction to Tori, and based on all the comments and my own interests, I landed on From the Choirgirl Hotel, Night of the Hunters, and In Times of Dragons.

My first post is here: [https://www.reddit.com/r/toriamos/comments/1tgi28a/getting\_into\_tori/](https://www.reddit.com/r/toriamos/comments/1tgi28a/getting_into_tori/)

Then I made a follow-up post: [https://www.reddit.com/r/toriamos/comments/1tih83a/brand\_new\_fan\_checking\_in/](https://www.reddit.com/r/toriamos/comments/1tih83a/brand_new_fan_checking_in/) as people had asked to read more along my journey, and I wrote a track-by-track response to In Times of Dragons.

People again requested more, and someone in particular asked for my reactions to Night of the Hunters - so here I am again!!!

\----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ok, SO! I don't think I realized going in that this was going to be a string and wind ensemble performing songs based on classical works, with Tori singing a melody and lyrics to go along with it... and I just want to say...

...THANK YOU SO MUCH to whomever recommended I put this in my 3 intro albums!!!

This is *exactly* what I meant by wanting to see her range. This is nothing like Dragons or Choirgirl, and it's *so fucking cool*. Already on first listen, this is my second favourite of the three (Dragons is still my favourite, though!!)

I'm not sure how the person who suggested this album knew ;) but I have a classical background and some of my favourite composers (Mendelssohn, Mussorgsky, Debussy) and a few others I really like (Satie, Schubert) are here! She definitely has a very Latin taste in composers, whereas I've mostly preferred the Russians, but there's plenty of overlap here ;)

Anyway, this is *such* an enjoyable listen for me and I frankly wish (hope??) she had (has??) more like this!!!

It speaks volumes about her talent and skill to be able to do this. This is harder than writing full songs, in my opinion - it's definitely at minimum a much more niche ability, and it certainly demonstrates to me why she's so good at writing such complex songs like on Dragons... she has a profound love and understanding for classical music. She thoroughly understands time signatures, key signatures, chord progressions, intervals, etc, etc, etc...

I am only halfway through my first listen now, and am already motivated to post about it - that's how good it is. My favourite so far is Star Whisperer. I am indeed a Schubert enjoyer, but even bias aside, that was simply a gorgeous arrangement.

I also really enjoy her first original song on the album, Job's Coffin. Very lovely.

Seven Sisters, her other original on the album, is even more wonderful. Adore the piano contrasting with the clarinet <3 Another favourite track alongside Star Whisperer <3

\------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Alright, I'm on my second listen now, and writing down my thoughts as I go through :) Here's my track-by-track response! To anyone who enjoyed my responses to Dragons, just know this is going to be *very* different - I immediately felt Dragons as a concept album and many of my feelings and reactions were to motifs in the music. With this one, I have apparently responded mostly to the classical elements, the instrumentation, and Tori's balance and contrasts with the ensemble. :) So, here we go!

Shattering Sea - the intro is so powerful, and I love how this dramatic build falls into the simplicity of the piano, but still driving forward hard. I very much feel the drama of the powerful sea. She makes the piano work absolutely seamlessly into this arrangement. When it spills into the desolate space around 3:00, but then slowly builds with the violins and then the echoing parts in the vocals, I feel such intensifying energy, and then we slide right back into the piano/vocal combo from the beginning. A great start to the album!

Snowblind - a serene and gorgeous transition here, after that intense start! I love how this starts with just the piano, and then the oboe just sneaks in there in the background... it's a stunning accompaniment. And with the complimentary voices together with the piano and oboe, this is just \*muah\*. Absolutely stunning. I love how minimalistic this feels after the previous song. Already hearing a huge range in just the first two tracks.

Battle of Trees - I love how creepy-ish this starts off. Piques my curiosity as to what we're going to be experiencing here. The early prominence of the cello - one of my favourite instruments - really takes it up a number of notches for me. Even going so far as to having two harmonizing cellos <3 Wow, this is so darkly gorgeous. Favourite track so far. Around 2:45 gives me chills. Not terribly surprising I like this one so much, though, considering it's based on Satie ;) But I feel a need now to listen to Gnossienne now, side by side :D

Fearlessness - maybe my least favourite so far - it's very pretty, but it doesn't feel like too much happens in this one compared to the first few. Maybe the piece it's based on just isn't so much my thing. But I do really like the part from around 4:30, and the build to the end.

Cactus Practice - ooh, interesting start! This has a stark contrast of playfulness/childishness and darkness. Love the winds here so much - especially that bassoon, one of my other favourite instruments <3 This song feels like it has a bit of a verse-chorus structure, unlike the others so far. Second favourite so far after Battle of Trees. Oh. I just checked and it's based on Chopin - that explains some of the vibe in the winds :) I actually love what she did vocally on this one, though - I feel this is the most clever vocal writing she's done so far on the album in combination with the instrumentals.

Star Whisperer - ugh, yes. That fucking intro! Pure contra-bass and bass clef piano... and timbre of her voice... I'm *strapped in* for this ride! Everything is just so stunning here... her voice is absolutely perfect, her piano part... it fits perfectly with the winds and strings... this is just perfect synergy. At 3:00, you think the song is over... but no, the best is still to come... a shift to hopefulness after the bleak darkness... this part actually starts to sound more like a Tori Amos song... and I'm lost in those dissonant intervals on the piano... and then the striking cello... ooof... dueting with the viola... and then we get that driving bass from the contrabassoon... which is another thing I love about this. It is not at all common to make your sole bass instrument a contrabass bassoon. Like, wtaf? That's so fucking weird and I am absolutely in love with it <3

Job's Coffin - an original in the mix, and she works it in so, so well. This whole album speaks to her skill (and talent), but including original works and making it so that if you didn't look it up, you wouldn't know that some are originals and some are based on famous classical works is an actual testament of musical genius. Yes, this has some pop vibes that are obviously not in the previous songs - the chord progression, and the song's structure - but we know from other albums that she loves to write songs that do not strictly follow pop structures (like 23 Peaks), so to some extent, one could assume she intended this to be a bit of a "pop" respite in a fairly inaccessible album ;)

Nautical Twilight - gorgeous, of course, I mean it's Mendelssohn ;) Love her melodies here! And her choice of triplets in the piano part with those strings... this one is really up there... the piano features very prominently here - I feel it really stands out, with the other instruments adorning, which is very cool on this album.

Your Ghost - this and the next one are based on composers I really don't like (Schumann and Bach), so I'm automatically less inclined to love these. The first portion is very sing-songy haha I don't really have much to say about this one for the first couple minutes, but from 2:00 it gets prettier. I like the second half better, but I guess it just loses me a bit.

Edge of the Moon - I have a very strong bias against Bach haha so I would not expect to like this at all. I really like the tone of her voice here, though. The bassoon is very cute around 2:00, and the clarinet comes beautifully then. But I have to admit that the first half of this is fairly boring for me. Then when she takes over with the piano in the second half, and the doubled up vocals, it gets *good*. I like this a lot. I have a feeling this half is not very based on Bach anymore ;) I'm not willing to look up the piece it's based on to find out, because I don't want to listen to Bach :D But yes to the second half of this song, and if the first half was necessary to set up the second half, then I'm on board :)

The Chase - Ok. Guys and gals. Mussorgsky is one of my favourite composers, and Pictures at an Exhibition is one of my favourite classical pieces of all time. However, the part of the piece she chose to use is not one of my favourite parts of the piece :D So that stops this from easily and instantly being the best track on the album. I really do love the vocals, though. This is the piece I know the best of all the ones she used for this album, and it demonstrates for me how "based on" works on this album, and I'm blown away. Yes, I hear *Pictures* a bit here, but I mostly hear The Chase. It is not Pictures at an Exhibition. It's a completely different song. I do really want more of that one. It ends way too soon!

Night of Hunters - I'm not at all familiar with the source material for this one, but I really enjoy it. It deserves to be the title track. I love the "watching over/keeping watch" section a lot. This one is a vocal standout on the album. ESPECIALLY around 5:00!!! Wow! And that powerful ending! Gorgeous.

Seven Sisters - I love this one so much. What's especially impressive is it actually kind of has classical vibes to it and almost does feel like it could've been written at that time, despite it having been written by Tori - and I really love that clarinet <3

Carry - well, Debussy <3 Of course it's gorgeous and a perfect closer! Oops, I honestly got a little bit lost in the music and forgot to write anything :) Debussy really has that lullaby effect on me haha and her voice really adds to that here :) Love her melody with the music for this one. Lots of bassoon here, too, making me very happy - but my favourite is her melody and voice in the "you will not be forgotten" bits.

— 0