Orange Cake - Crazy Success ! (mostly)
Hello All,
Tl;dr: sour cream, olive oil, mandarin slices diced, pomegranate & orange soda, candied orange slices and ... no eggs!
First I want to thank the TJ'ers who educated me about the mix - I had bought it on a whim (PMS for the win!) and then based on lurking, discovered the mix left a lot to be desired BUT also discovered some ideas of how to improve it So ... credit goes to you all!
PS see note at the bottom - I didn't add the 2 eggs. I was multitasking to beat the band and just forgot them.
I ended up adding 2 Tbsps of sour cream, a Tbsp of olive oil, the zest of an entire orange, replacing the 3/4 cups of water with San Pellagrino Pomegranate & Orange soda (I couldn't find SP's Blood Orange & Orange soda) AND the last delightful ingredient ... TJ's dried Mandarin Orange sections! I removed as much pith as I could from the Mandarin sections and then diced them into small bits.
When the cake was baked, I also used a chopstick to penetrate the cake and infuse it with TJ's fresh orange juice.
Before I poured the mix into the 8 X 4 metal cake pan, I also laid TJ's dried candied Orange Slices on the bottom of the pan - I thought it might make the cake look pretty (which it did. I didn't use them within the cake b/c them seemed ...tough but when baked they caramelized and slightly broke down so that they were easy to cut and to chew.
So the cake took longer to bake than normal but my stove is screwy so ... I kept doing the toothpick cake batter trick until the toothpick (in this case, a chopstick) came out clean.
The cake broke apart when I went to dislodge it, I did wait the suggested time but between my temperamental stove's temperature controls and lest we forget ... no eggs; I'm not sure why. But better bakers than I may be able to offer explanation.
Bottom line ... the cake ended up delicious. Very, very moist - tear off a section and you can roll it into a ball, the orange slices were tender and added a considerable amount of authentic orange flavor but NO unpleasant chew, and the Mandarin bits were ... delightful!
I believe the pomegranate soda and the sour cream mitigated the 'fake orange tootsie pop flavor' b/c they both added some tangy, sour elements and the Mandarin orange bits with the orange juice added fresh authentic orange taste.
I'm not a baker of cakes - pies, tarts, scones, etc yes but cakes? No. I don't have any cake pans and had to buy an 8 X 4 cake pan to do this But I shopped this around to a bunch of neighbors and they all LOVED it.
Extra PS partially b/c the cake didn't make it out of the pan; I did not use the icing included in the mix. But I think it turned out better for not having it. My opinion.
​
BUT ... go forth and bake! I'm looking forward to all of the critiques and suggestions and reports back about how it worked for you! I would love to know how this worked for you!