RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/trains • … • u/SharkyCartel_ACU

Why didn't the Pennsylvania Railroad use Articulated or Mallets much?

It seems like they did almost everything to avoid using any Mallet/Articulated locomotives, even on their steeper trackage like West of Altoona, Southern Ohio, Appalachian routes, etc.

They made a Texas type (J1), split a Northern in half but kept it's rigid frame (The T1), and even built what is essentially a 4-10-4 but put two sets of drivers on instead of just keeping one set of pistons to power 10 wheels (Q1 and Q2). I know they had a 2-8-8-2 but it seems it wasn't utilized much (if at all).

So what was keeping them from just splitting the frame and building something like an NW Class A or a Yellowstone? Why did they love their duplexes and Texans so much that they didn't really move beyond a single Chesapeake produced? It just seems odd to me.

— 0